Hierarchy of the cups: a take on the place of domestic trophies in English football

By Jack Paul

What is a football club’s ultimate goal? To get promoted, win the league, achieve financial sustainability, or just make their fans happy? Depends on the club, depends on the situation, you might say. The material realities of each club are vastly different, and their ambitions vary accordingly.

However, that feels like a wholly unsatisfying answer. Alan Shearer’s comments in the build-up to the League Cup final raised this very question for his club, Newcastle United.

The Premier League’s record goal scorer affirms that for the Magpies, winning the Carabao Cup would be a bigger and more important step than qualifying for the Champions League.

Ask any football fan and their response will likely be different. For my club, Arsenal, getting back to European football – which looks very much in reach this season – has been prioritised over domestic cups. In fact, the Gunners have been knocked out at the early stages in both the Carabao and League Cup tournaments.

Manager Mikel Arteta maintains that he plays the team likeliest to get a result in any given game. In the midst of an unexpected title challenge, however, sacrifices have to be made. That was very much the attitude after a rotated side was beaten by Brighton at the Emirates in the initial round of the League Cup: there are bigger fish to fry.

The much-maligned cup was treated, at least by the fan base, as an unnecessary distraction from broader, loftier ambitions. Despite the fact Arsenal’s trophy cabinet contains not a single League Cup, most fans were happy enough to focus on league results and allow this one to fall by the wayside.

Although pride is taken in relation to the Gunners’ FA Cup record, having in won it more than anyone else, there was little concern after their exit this year

The exit from the FA Cup was viewed similarly. More than high stakes game of knockout football, the game was seen as preview of the pivotal clash between two title contenders a week later.

Manchester City were eventually victorious in both ties, but the reaction to each game offered an insight into the supporters’ mindset towards the hierarchy of competitions.

Although pride is taken in relation to the Gunners’ FA Cup record, having in won it more than anyone else, there was little concern after their exit this year. In fact, most fans took encouragement from the performance away at the Etihad. The club had gone toe to toe with their Premier League title rivals whose full line-up of stars was on display.

A team who had been consistently at the top of the table were knocked off and many amongst us wrote off the title challenge as a result

Arsenal opted to make significant changes to a team which throughout their league campaign has remained constant. In fact, the North London side have made the fewest changes to their first XI this season. But when it came to a cup game in the middle of a packed schedule, Arteta made his priories clear.

Little weight was given to the result itself by the Arsenal faithful. “Oh well, let’s focus on the league then was once again” was the mantra. The game, which ended 1-0 to Manchester City, could have gone either way and some fans were even pleased not to have the unwelcome distraction of cup football while the blue side of Manchester would have to continue fighting on several fronts.

The reaction to the league game which followed could not have been more different: complete meltdown. A team who had been consistently at the top of the table were knocked off and many amongst us wrote off the title challenge as a result.

Guardiola’s men would now inevitably march on to victory. That’s how it felt. As always in football, things change rapidly. Arsenal were back on top within four days after a dramatic 4-2 win against Aston Villa and Manchester City’s surprise draw at Nottingham Forest.

Regardless of who eventually lifts the Premier League trophy, these reactions clearly demonstrate where some clubs’ priorities lie.

Then why do Arsenal fans so universally scoff at the chance of domestic silverware, while Alan Shearer thinks the Carabao Cup is just what Newcastle need? I suspect the former England striker’s comments would be more divisive among Newcastle fans but, within the context of where they are as a club, he has a point.

For a club of such stature, this barren run is truly shocking

The club from the North East has not won a trophy of any note since the Inter-City Fairs Cup in 1969, before Shearer was even born. For their last domestic cup, you have to go all the way back to an FA Cup victory in 1955.

For a club of such stature, this barren run is truly shocking. Is it a case of just win any old trophy so there is something to shout about? The financial incentives of the League Cup are nothing to get excited about; but, within the context of a state-owned team with seemingly infinite resources, this matters little.

So, what would do more for their reputation and the so called ‘project’? I would argue that qualification for European competition would allow them to attract a higher calibre of player and therefore accelerate their progress towards the biggest trophies.

Either way, Newcastle’s resurgence is well ahead of schedule. No one thought they would be this good, this quickly. Building a competitive team is challenging and even with the amount of money at their disposal it won’t be a straight shot towards the top of the game.

This said, their trajectory is promising and despite their loss in the final to Manchester United, they are clearly on the path to success.

On the other hand, this flippant attitude towards cup competitions could leave Arsenal with nothing concrete, or indeed silver, to show for their efforts at the end of the season.

However, for a chance at winning what really matters to them – getting back to the glory of the Invincibles and achieving the greatest goal of our project – that’s a risk willing to take.

Image: Joshjdss via Flickr