Imposter syndrome: should more be done at Durham?
By Joshua Guillen
Social isolation, better expressed as imposter syndrome, is a phenomenon predicated on the idea that people, through no fault of their own, are subjected to unjust asymmetries that impact negatively on their ability to socialise, work or accrue opportunities. This is predominantly something experienced in the world of work: a reported 38% of the workforce suffer from sentiments linked to imposter syndrome, with data suggestive of a further fall in job confidence as a result of the pandemic.
What is clear, however, is that insecurity of this kind is not exclusively reserved to employment prospects; the last 18 months have served to underline how social and economic inequalities are pervasive across all reaches of society. This diffidence is broadly applicable to British higher education: recent trends point to a growing socioeconomic chasm in offer rates from Russell Group universities — even in cases where projected grades are indistinguishable between students of different backgrounds.
These inequalities should necessarily be considered as core enabling factors in the fomentation of social-based anxieties on campus, especially as they relate to Durham University. The unbalanced nature of admissions, whereby a sustained increase in admissions from the nation’s wealthiest areas has outdone those from the poorest areas, engenders a broader dissonance in the University’s long-term strategy. The resultant consequences are explicit: heightened disconnect from within the student community will likely lead to more incidents of abuse and explicit classism, despite the current push to create a more diverse student body at the University.
Imposter syndrome is as much a social problem as it is a structural one
What is clear, however, is that imposter syndrome is as much a social problem as it is a structural one. In essence, if a university like Durham is ill-equipped to provide holistic, responsive support to marginalised individuals, there is no feasible path for a more diverse, representative student demography to be procured. Testimonies from Durham students from the north of England accentuate the entrenched institutional inertia of the University in dealing with prejudiced and “toxic” attitudes; students of colour have previously reported a culture of racism; and the sociology department recently issued an open letter to the University over the treatment of working-class students.
This underscores an indelible criticism often echoed in the national press: Durham University has helped in the normalisation of a set of behavioural patterns that have served to erode the virtues of meritocratic attainment felt by those of less fortunate beginnings. The University has since reaffirmed its ambition to create a more equitable student experience, but concerns remain about the efficacy of its proposed path.
Here, it is important to stress that steps have been taken to broaden accessibility to Durham, with the introduction of the Brian Cooper scholarship fund one such innovation designed to extend opportunity to the immediate region of County Durham. Yet, despite it being illustrative of a shift in strategic direction, the latest figures of student intake demonstrate how its impact has been superficial; Durham, like the majority of Russell Group universities, continues to perform poorly for student diversity — even when performance and attainment are measured.
Durham continues to perform poorly for student diversity
This broader national imbalance may supersede the capabilities of one single institution to resolve on its own, but the reported cases of discrimination at Durham University demand that a more accountable framework is adopted to tackle the unjust prejudices on campus. The work of student groups and societies remain key catalysts for student- led change, but sustainable cultural reform is increasingly seen as a matter for the University itself.
The challenge is two-pronged for Durham: first, a more representative admission process that better reflects merit through widening the net to different communities; second, a less convoluted system of student support should be instituted to promote wellbeing for those who feel marginalised. This could, if greeted with the necessary urgency, help to minimise the daunting and perturbed sentiments of imposter syndrome.
Image: John Russell/Vanderbilt University via Flickr

