Confusing, complacent and contradictory: government messaging during the pandemic
By Joshua Guillen
Catalysed by a deadly and invisible virus, our relationship with the government has drastically altered. Whether it be through the protracted lockdowns of 2020 or the administration of a vaccine roll-out, we have come to chart our behaviours by referring more explicitly than ever to what the government permits us to do.
In the context of a virulent disease, such action can, with strong oversight and reciprocity, be permissible. Yet, as demonstrated by the recent fiasco in Bolton, whereby travel was limited to ‘essential’ but was uncommunicated to the public, a befuddling lack of clarity has characterised much of the governmental response to coronavirus. Such a failure is hardly an outlier; the confusion prompted in May over international travel was, ironically, too convoluted even for a government spokesman to coherently explain.
This, however, is symptomatic of a wider flaw of pandemic-era discourse. As I am sure will be remembered, the powerfully simplistic slogans employed in response to the spread of the disease have been stark; “stay at home, protect the NHS, save lives”; “hands, face, space”; “stay alert, control the virus, save lives”. Although emotively sharp and unambiguous, such a ‘sloganistic’ approach to public relations has been problematic on a number of levels.
A befuddling lack of clarity has characterised much of the governmental response to coronavirus
Take, for instance, the relationship between accountability and rhetoric. Despite being succinct and semantically impactful, the overreliance on such messaging distorts scientific and political realities. In seeking to be the face of policy to the public, it entrenches the idea that government strategy can be reduced to a singular, minimalistic line of messaging. Ironically, these bold phrases have complexified the eligibility of pandemic-related measures to the public; university policy, travel and holiday restrictions, funerals and lower education have all been subject to muddled reasoning and botched justification. So much for reciprocity.
What is perhaps most preoccupying, though, is that past missteps appear to be forgotten all too easily. As is often the case with the current administration, prudence seems to be superseded by chaos; Johnson had suggested in November, for example, that football stadiums could be working at minimal capacity by December. Such an announcement was ill-fated: despite resuming on 2nd December, fans were promptly back watching on from the living room couch. Indeed, a similar U-turn came with the polemic over Christmas which, having been pinpointed to be as “normal as possible”, was also reversed for the majority of the country. This to-ing and fro-ing has, in many respects, diluted the importance of coherent, understable health-based policy.
It is here, then, that the most profound criticism of the government can come. Coupled with far-fetched optimism and pandemic idealism, the demonstrable lack of foresight exhibited by Johnson has depleted the efficacy of his own government’s pandemic messaging. It isn’t that I didn’t want fans to return to stadia last winter. Neither was it the case that I wanted people to be away from family at Christmas. Rather, it was the very fact that doing these things contradicted the substance and intention of the advice designed to help suppress the virus.
Sufficient levels of communication and transparency are vital features of any healthy, working democracy
We have seen similar criticisms surface abroad, too, with the presidency of Donald Trump being an extreme example of how mixed messaging and distorted ideas of the virus can be dangerous. His incoherent speeches on all manner of absurdities, particularly that of his infamous suggestion of injecting disinfectant, emphasises this claim. It came as no surprise, then, that by the time his term in the White House was coming to an end, death and infection rates remained at record levels.
If there is anything we can take from the last year, it is that sufficient levels of communication and transparency are vital features of any healthy, working democracy. Both functionally and philosophically, democracies are fundamentally imperfect and, whilst regimes with less accountability have marketed themselves as being better managers of this pandemic, such efforts are shrouded in a lack of political and legal rights.
The lesson remains, though. The UK, like the US, must be clearer and more upfront when it comes to making and explaining decisions. This is all the more significant within the context of a pandemic which threatens to bite back once more.
Image: Number 10 via Flickr.

