Importance of FA Cup shows issues within Football

by Henry Clare
May 14th, 1988. For 90 minutes the world stopped, as English Champions Liverpool met unfancied Wimbledon in the FA Cup final.
Families around the globe sat in unison, glued to their television screens. The match itself kicked off at 3pm, but the build-up will have begun at the crack of dawn, and the post match reaction will have run deep into the night.
The match proved to be a high point in the history of the FA Cup. Bobby Gould’s ‘crazy gang’ stunned Kenny Dalglish’s ‘culture club’, as Wimbledon pulled off the most unlikely of victories.
The FA Cup was the jewel in the English football calendar’s crown. A quarter of a century on, and the FA Cup is becoming nothing more than an excuse for sentimentality in a sport that increasingly makes no allowance for romanticism.
The 1988 final evokes images of Wembley’s iconic twin towers, of fans staying up all night to watch their teams do battle, and the best players in world football kitting it out on the biggest stage. Football today is ever-increasingly a game of numbers, and the most important of those numbers seems to be cash flow.
Where clubs were once owned by romantics who dreamt of cup success, today super rich oligarchs looking for a return on their investment dominate the game. Slowly but surely, football clubs are becoming nothing more than part of a business portfolio.
For a Premier League side, the financial rewards of winning the league, or qualifying for the Champions League, or even simply staying in the league, far exceed those gained by lifting the FA Cup. The winners of the FA Cup receive £1.8 million, whereas loss of TV revenue alone due to relegation costs £21 million.

Even if super rich owners don’t care about the FA Cup, surely football managers do? No. Football has become a cut-throat game. Owners demand success, and demand it immediately. The simple fact of the matter is that if managers don’t succeed, then they will be chucked out the back door.
It is therefore in the best interests of football managers to keep these cold businessmen happy; in truth the once idealistic dream of throwing away league success for the sake of a run in the FA Cup holds no stock with modern day owners.
So much is the importance of the league, and it’s financial rewards, that the FA Cup is not just an irrelevance, but an inconvenience as well. Mangers like Paul Lambert and Sam Allardyce have recently demonstrated that they would rather rest their players for league games than gamble in the hope of winning the FA Cup.
That simply is not what football should be about; it is about reaching peaks, creating drama, and achieving glory. Last summer, Wigan Athletic won the FA Cup, but suffered the misfortune of relegation from the top flight.
In the eyes of most modern day owners this was a failure and naivety on the part of Roberto Martinez, who fielded his strongest possible side for the final. But ask any devoted Wigan fan, and they will tell you that seeing their heroes lift the FA Cup was one of the best moments of their life.
If the next generation of fans, players and managers grow up believing that bank balances are more important than trophies, then football in England will die a slow but steady death.
We need to change the culture of the game, before it’s too late.
Photographs: Matthew Vining & Football Collective
