‘I’m still here’ (2024): memory and resistance under military junta
By Luca Bavasso
Content Warning: this article contains references to violence, which some readers may find upsetting.
Rio de Janeiro. Wednesday 20th January, 1971. Rubens Paiva was abducted by armed security agents from his beachfront home, leaving behind his wife, children, and a silence that stretched decades.
Paiva was a moderate leftist, not a steadfast radical. Outspoken against the military dictatorship that stifled Brazil from 1964 to 1984, he was stripped of his Congressional role and pushed into self-exile. Upon his return, he quietly settled down with his family amidst the gentle hum of Ipanema beach. His return coincided with the ascension of Emílio Garrastazu Medici, the “hardest of the regime’s hardliners.”
Paiva was living the unassuming life of a Brazilian bien pensant repatriate. Yet, on that January morning, he would forever vanish into the machinery of the military dictatorship, under the suspicion of involvement in subversive activities against the state. Beneath the façade of sun-soaked bliss in early 1970s Rio lies an unmarked cell door, behind which Paiva was brutally tortured and killed. His body was never found.
Walter Salles’ I’m Still Here (2024) recounts the impact of this disappearance, not strictly through graphic sequences in dark interrogation rooms, but through the quiet devastation that lingered in the Paiva household. Salles traces the defiance of Ruben’s widow, Eunice (Fernanda Torres), in a confrontation of Brazil’s political past that remains to be fully reckoned with today.
The film moves across three chapters – 1971, 1996, and 2014 – entwining memory with the present to reinforce a central truth: the dictatorship may have fallen, but its wounds remain tender. Following the 2022 Brazilian election, far-right militants allied to former President Bolsonaro staged an unsuccessful coup to overthrow newly elected Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. In the wake of a violent challenge to democracy reminiscent of the fateful 1964 coup, Lula declared: “Today is the day to say it loud and clear. We’re still here.”
Entwining memory with the present to reinforce a central truth: the dictatorship may have fallen, but its wounds remain tender
The film opens to the buzz of family life in early 1970s Rio, a joyful chaos strung together by sequences of beach volleyball and celebration. Salles invites us into the whirl of the Paiva’s home, alive with youthful laughter and liberal discussion interrupted only by the pouring of whiskey or the lighting of a cigar. Yet, the threat of violence feels agonisingly imminent. The energy is unsettled by the rumbling of Brazil’s military dictatorship, as helicopters circle and armed convoys cut through Salles’ idyllic Ipanema.
This threat quickly takes hold of the narrative. “Forced disappearances were one of the cruellest acts of the regime”, Eunice reflects to a reporter towards the end of the film. The abduction of Rubens Paiva epitomised a wider system of repression, which intensified under generalissimo Médici, the third of five military rulers during Brazil’s 21 years of martial law.
Upon his ascension to power in 1969, Médici redefined authoritarianism for Brazilians, presiding over a period governed by press censorship, state surveillance, and the systematic purging of left-wing opponents. The regime’s unprecedented use of military force was leveraged against the economic boom of the ‘Brazilian Miracle’ and nationwide euphoria following World Cup glory in 1970. It normalised forced disappearances and extra-judicial killings as an instrument for state control. Under Médici, opponents of the regime were not only silenced but rendered invisible.
Under Médici, opponents of the regime were not only silenced but rendered invisible
After 1971, Eunice Paiva dedicated her life to ensuring that this erasure didn’t go unchallenged. Fernanda Torres delivers a career-defining performance, inhabiting Eunice’s struggle with a subtle intensity well-deserving of Oscar recognition and a Golden Globe award. As the narrative flows into the 21st century, Torres’ intelligence and measure charts the widow’s evolution into a staunch human-rights advocate, a tireless pursuit for justice, which compelled the state to finally issue an official death certificate for her late husband in 1996.
Torres’ performance shimmers against Adrian Teijido’s rich cinematography. The film is shot on 35mm, giving the opening sun-kissed domestic scenes a charmingly lived-in texture, with a grainy quality that effectively conveys the grit of Eunice Paiva’s resistance. Sequences of the Paiva’s home-movie footage are also embedded throughout the film. Shot in Super 8 mm (a popular format in 1970s South America), the fuzzy images of a now fractured family life emphasise the importance of memory in the face of oppression. It is precisely this memory of Brazilian authoritarianism that I’m Still Here refuses to shy away from.
“It would have been unthinkable to shoot this film during the Bolsonaro years,” says Salles, reminding us that Brazil’s turbulent history isn’t quite as distant as it seems. In South America, democratic norms have become increasingly fragile: militaries retain political influence and leaders flirt with authoritarian rhetoric. Recent disruptions in Brazil, Peru, and Venezuela have tested national institutions and proven that the lessons of the past remain unresolved. I’m Still Here turns to the government as a reminder of its responsibility to not just recognise its legacy, but to confront it.
In 1996, Eunice Paiva was asked, “Doesn’t the government have more urgent issues than fixing the past?”
“No,” she replied.
Image: Arquivo Pessoal via Wikipedia Creative Commons

