Cold truths: An exploration of snowbound cinema

By Luca Bavasso

“When Chekhov saw the long winter, he saw a winter bleak and dark and bereft of hope. Yet we know that winter is just another step in the cycle of life”. – Groundhog Day (1993)

After having been condemned to relive the same February day in the small town of Punxsutawney, Phil Collins (Bill Murray) closes Groundhog Day with a redemptive meditation on seasonal transience and the human capacity for renewal. The misanthropic weatherman gazes into the warm eyes of Rita Hanson (Andie MacDowell) as he tells the local television crew that he “couldn’t imagine a better fate than a long and lustrous winter”. The winter season is impermanent by definition and, as this comedy classic reminds us, often lends itself best to self-reflection and growth; a comforting mantra to hold onto as we slip into the cold months once more.

Nevertheless, it is precisely Chekhov’s vision of winter that has informed many of the snowbound masterpieces of modern cinema. Leading filmmakers have often embraced the cold not as a signal for renewal, but as a force which strips characters down to their rawest, most morally compromised form.

For the Coen brothers, the snow-cloaked Minnesotan expanse serves as the moral canvas for their homespun crime classic: Fargo (1996). Perhaps ironically, the noir is marked by a stark whiteness which amplifies the absurd violence that unfolds in the bleak Midwest. The Coens take us on the journey of police chief Marge Gunderson (Frances McDormand) investigating the murders of two locals and a state trooper, rapidly unravelling into an offbeat tale of brutality and moral corruption. The cold snowscape of Fargo is soaked in violence, repeatedly exposing the missteps of incompetent thugs Carl (Steve Buscemi) and Gaear (Peter Stormare) throughout the film. Marge immediately makes headway in her case as she stumbles across footprints that betray the criminals, whilst the white planes of the local Minnesotan town are stained with fresh blood. But it is this very same snow which simultaneously conceals wrongdoing, as Carl seeks to bury within it his illicit spoils. The frosty climate is uncompromising, driving the narrative forward in constant interaction with each character’s ambitions – for better or for worse.

Cinematic representations of winter often take the traditional Western mythos and spin it on its head. This is certainly true of Tarantino’s The Hateful Eight (2015), lauded as the definitive revisionist interpretation of the fabled genre in recent memory. At its core, the film adopts a multitude of typically Western tropes: bounty hunters, post-Civil war tensions and a violent confrontation between the law and the lawless. Yet, Tarantino flips these devices inwardly, quite literally, as the protagonists are barricaded within Minnie’s Haberdashery at the mercy of a blizzard outside. The surrounding environment is therefore mobilised as an active force, stripping the ensemble of their mobility and forcing moral decay to fester within the cabin. In this claustrophobic whiteout, the sprawling desert planes of The Searchers (1956) and Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) are throttled by Tarantino’s harsh winter, compressing the drama into a chamber piece where depravity and distrust take hold:

One of them fellas is not what he says he is…

Tying up a year defined by snowbound cinema, Alejandro J. Iñárritu’s The Revenant (2015) epitomises Chekov’s vision of the desolate and unforgiving season. A harsh winter dominates the expanses of 1820s Montana and South Dakota, as we follow the Hugh Glass (Leonardo Di Caprio) on a relentless odyssey of survival. The cold gradually becomes the principal antagonist, forcing Glass to navigate an implacable landscape of icy rivers and snowy domains. Earning him an Academy Award in 2016, Emmanuel Lubezki’s cinematography is characterised by vast, sweeping shots, expertly dragging us through the wilderness alongside the protagonist such that one almost feels a twisted sense of comfort when Glass finds shelter inside the carcass of his horse. The Revenant presents human behaviour at its extreme, where morality is tested and mankind is laid bare in its most primitive form. For Iñárritu and his peers, winter is harnessed not only as an aesthetic choice, but as a defining force which shapes narrative and dissects human nature.

Filmmakers use winter to underscore explorations of human behaviour at the height of adversity. Yet such profound self-reflection equally points to an opportunity for renewal, and it is precisely this hope that prompted Phil Collins to declare that he “couldn’t imagine a better fate than a long and lustrous winter”. However, were he to step into the snowbound realms of a Coen, Tarantino or Iñárritu winter, perhaps he ought to think twice.

Illustration Credit: Hayleigh McLean