“I wish I was a gay man”: entertainment or fetishisation?

By Luisa Pittan-Doring

Heated Rivalry has become a sensation worldwide, with many, myself included, re-watching more than once. Despite being produced on a modest budget, the show has reached over 10.6 million viewers in the United States alone, with that number more than doubling after the show’s finale. Yet its impact extends beyond viewership; some hockey players have privately thanked the actors for helping them open closet doors in a sports world that remains deeply conservative. The show follows Canadian Shane Hollander and Russia’s Ilya Rozanov over the course of a decade, as they fall in love within the hyper-masculine hockey culture of the 2000s. After the first episode, my cousin, who introduced me to the show, proclaimed “I wish I was a gay man,” a phrase that has remained with me since. The series features numerous explicit sex scenes, and it is here that such comments begin to raise ethical concerns. 

Female viewers make up roughly two thirds of the show’s demographic. Women are truly enthralled by Hollander and Rozanov. I can personally attest to the show’s impact on my own social circles, with constant messages flooding our group chat, of course titled “The Cottage”. We share fan edits, behind-the-scenes footage, interview clips, and have endless discussions dissecting every line delivery and body language. But how did we get here? How has this show reached such an intensity of devotion? And more provocatively, are women fetishising male-loving-male (MLM) relationships, particularly those that are sexually explicit? At first glance, the argument seems compelling. Audiences have always gravitated toward tropes such as forbidden love or enemies-to-lovers, as they dramatise emotional risk and reward. But when the obsession appears to intersect with sexuality, controversy emerges. Feminists, myself included, have criticised heterosexual men’s obsession with lesbian pornography, which reduces women to objects existing solely for male pleasure. How is this any different? 

My take is that Heated Rivalry fans are being profoundly misunderstood. Women are, once again, being flattened into one-dimensional consumers of romance driven purely by sexual titillation. Yes, sex is a big part of the show’s appeal but if that were the sole appeal, there would be no shortage of alternatives online. Yet, Heated Rivalry has cultivated something far deeper than momentary arousal. What captured audiences’ hearts was the emotional architecture of the story. The slow burn, the forbidden love, the enemies-to-lovers dynamic, the opposites-attract tension. It was the careful layering of intimacy over time, the glances that linger longer than they should, the tension in silence, the emotional vulnerability that emerges despite every effort to suppress it. 

What we do wish, is to every so often, live vicariously through a love story that feels void of misogyny

But there is also another lens to examine which explains so pointedly the intensity of the female fan-base toward MLM storylines: escapism. In heterosexual romance, the gender of female characters defines how they move through the world and how the audience interprets them. The tropes are always the same. The career-driven woman who must learn to “soften,” (How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, The Proposal), the emotionally guarded woman who must learn to trust (10 Things I Hate About You, and dare I say The Notebook?), the independent woman whose strength is framed as a barrier to love (People We Meet on Vacation, Pretty Woman). Her gender is always at the very core of her character and the wider story. 

In Heated Rivalry, however, the emotional intensity remains, but it is the gendered burden that disappears. What we witness between Shane and Ilya is yearning in its purest form. Over years of secrecy, their intimacy is shaped by mutual vulnerability rather than power. The masculinity they embody is not the problem; it is the heteronormative structures surrounding masculinity that so often tie it to dominance, threat, entitlement, and emotional restraint. Here, masculinity exists without those imperatives. It becomes gentle, nurturing. What makes their story so addictive is not the secrecy, a product of homophobic structures that forbid them from being together, but rather the safety they find in one another. This is also not to say only the male characters are written with depth and authenticity; the women are too. Yet, the love story does not belong to them. And paradoxically, that absence creates space for female viewers to breathe. For once, we are allowed to observe love from a distance, without inheriting its gendered consequences. Because as much as I love being a woman, it can be exhausting. We live in constant negotiation with systems that scrutinise and constrain us. Heated Rivalry offers a world where love exists outside those constraints. 

So no, women don’t actually “wish to be a gay man”. What we do wish, is to every so often, live vicariously though a love story that feels void of misogyny. To me, this is not fetishisation. It is escapism. 

Image: S. Yume via Wikimedia Commons