Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl halftime show: an act of defiance?
By Luísa Pittan-Doring
As a Brazilian who has lived abroad her entire life, I have grown used to the offhand comments, the “harmless” jokes, the mispronunciations, the borderline xenophobia that people disguise as curiosity. Even then, I cannot begin to fathom the fear Latinos in the United States are currently experiencing. Reports of deeply racialised targeting and a sharp escalation in ICE detentions have become increasingly common and televised, and have, in fact, quadrupled since this time last year, from 14,882 to 59,644 detentions. Under the presidency of Donald Trump, that escalation has felt less like an accident and more like policy enabled by rhetoric. When a political climate normalises language that dehumanises migrants – “they’re not humans, they’re animals” – the consequences are predictable.
Affirming that this marginalisation of Latin American communities in the US is new would be a blatant lie. What is new is the scale at which cultural visibility is colliding with political hostility.
However, many Latinos around the world have recently felt much needed hope with the news that Bad Bunny would headline the Super Bowl halftime show. At a time when anti-immigrant rhetoric dominates the news, seeing a Latino artist occupy one of the most watched stages in the US felt symbolic of hope. That is precisely why Donald Trump’s remark that “nobody understands a word this guy is saying” landed the way it did. While certainly predictable, it was not just belittling. He framed Spanish as foreign noise interrupting this great American spectacle. Yet, nearly one in five people in the United States is Hispanic, it is the language of millions of citizens, voters, workers, and artists who shape the country every single day, making the irony perhaps a little too on the nose, even for President Trump.
Affirming that this marginalisation of Latin American communities in the US is new would be a blatant lie. What is new is the scale at which cultural visibility is colliding with political hostility. Bad Bunny’s performance became a turning point precisely because it refused Americanisation. It was not diluted, not translated, notapologetic. It was Puerto Rican, and unmistakably Latino. In the choreography, in the imagery of sugar cane plantations, a quiet but pointed reminder of Latin American industries the United States has historically exploited, in the recreation of a local bar, ‘La Marqueta’, a space every Latino recognises instinctively. It was there in the nod to Ricky Martin, my mother’s own Bad Bunny, and even in the smallest, most intimate detail ofthe little boy asleep across a row of chairs at the end of a party. A scene so culturally specific, and yet so universal to many of us. I have been that child more times than I can count. So influential, in fact, that it prompted far-right conservatives to call for an alternative halftime spectacle, a ‘Turning Point’ initiative, a reaction that only underscored how disruptive authentic representation can be. Moreover, the songsperformed, including ‘El Apagón’, were not arbitrary. “Todos quieren ser latinos, pero les falta sazón” is not just a catchy lyric, but also a critique of commodified Latinidad. Everyone wants the rhythm, the aesthetic, the music and the cultural capital but few want to even acknowledge the politics attached to them. Representation matters in ways that are frankly difficult to quantify. Seeing someone who looks like you, speaks like you, references your history without explanation, it really means something. Ending his performance naming all of the countries in the American continent including Brazil, Chile, Bolivia, Argentina, Peru, Mexico, and more was the cherry on top. For communities often flattened into a monolith, specificity felt radical and special.
It would, however, be naïve to ignore the performative dimension of corporate entertainment. The Super Bowl likely selected Bad Bunny because he is so commercially dominant, and ultimately visibility sells. The Super Bowl is an event many watch solely for the halftime show. I, myself, could not tell you which teams were playing. And yet, it was saturated with tone-deaf advertising. Truth be told, the US loves to thrive on contradiction. While they commodify Latino culture, they also legislate against the very people that enable this diversification. While Benito’s performance was meant to celebrate Latin America, it was followed by an ICE advertisement, which might just be the ultimate kick in the teeth.
With that being said, I think it is important to keep the memory of Benito on stage a positive one. A Latino artist occupying that stage, unapologetically political, unapologetically Spanish-speaking, matters. It signals resistance. It offers representation not as tokenism but as a tangible presence. For Trump supporters, it is a reminder that Latinos are not peripheral, we are central. For the rest of us, his performance signifies something even more important: hope. As Bad Bunny himself has suggested in different forms throughout his work, love outlasts hostility. And in a political moment defined by exclusion, that assertion is far from redundant. It is defiant.
Image: U.S. Department of Defence Current Photos via Flickr

