Hunt’s Autumn Statement – economic game changer or election vote winner?

By James Nolan

With the intense scrutiny Rishi Sunak has faced in his first year as Prime Minister, it is easily forgotten the Chancellor has also recently celebrated one year in his role.  And, on 22nd November, as a belated gift, Jeremy Hunt had the chance to unveil the Autumn Statement, to a country desperate for some financial festive cheer.  Workers, business owners, and just about everyone else was tuned in, awaiting fiscal policy that would impact their pockets.

But, first, an assessment of the economy, since the Sunak and Hunt succession to Downing Street, of course.  Better, reported Hunt, immediately referring back to three economic points in his boss’ five priorities at the start of this year.  The Chancellor assessed that the government had successfully halved inflation, with the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) stating that the CPI measure fell to 4.6% for the year to October, down from 10.1% when the pledge was made in January.  Experts had expected inflation to fall irrespective of government policy, however, this is clearly a big tick for Hunt.  

However, there are more questions to be asked of his other assertions on the landscape of the economy.  Firstly, a look at his statement that the UK economy is growing.  Before the statement, the OBR gave a more optimistic forecast for growth for 2023 than had previously been anticipated.  This 0.6% growth prediction, as opposed to the 0.2% recession predicted in March, was lauded by Tories in the Commons.  However, the OBR has also revised down the March forecast for the next two years, from 1.8% to 0.7% for 2024 and 2.5% to 1.4% for 2025.  As a result, whilst Hunt will claim another priority has been met, clearly more needs to be done to meet the objective of long-term sustainable growth.  

Workers, business owners, and just about everyone else was tuned in, awaiting fiscal policy that would impact their pockets

On debt, a similar story.  OBR predictions that debt will fall from 2027 remain in place, and for 2023, the improved growth figures mean the debt and borrowing picture looks slightly better than anticipated.  However, the expectation for the British economy was always for debt, as a proportion of GDP, to fall, just like it was for inflation to fall, so, again, a success by the metrics of the current climate, but by no means should this annual level of debt reduction be a target.  It is clear the economy is in a more stable and manageable state than it was when Sunak and Hunt took over last October.  However, meeting an inflation target they were always expected to achieve will not be considered by everyone as a significant confidence raiser.   

After the impassioned defence of the current economic outlook, the next job for Hunt was to deliver new plans, with those three priorities very much in mind.  The Chancellor proudly proclaimed “110 growth measures”, aiming to “raise business investment, get more people into work, reduce inflation, and increase GDP”.  As with every fiscal event, the first thing people look for is tax legislation, and Hunt has made pledges to workers and businesses alike.  For many, the 2% reduction in National Insurance contribution will appeal.  As Hunt remarked, for someone on the average salary of £35,000, they will now save over £450.  He even announced this will come into play on January 6th, rather than for the new tax year in April, putting more money in the pockets of 27 million people, sooner.

However, compared to last year, it is likely this tax break will be ineffectual, with some even feeling worse off this winter.  If you cast your mind back to last year, every household received £400 to assist with paying energy bills over a six month period, a measure not being repeated this year.  Additionally, with wholesale gas prices increasing again since September, the energy regulator, OFGEM, announced just a day after the Autumn Statement that the energy price cap will increase by £94 from January, through March, for the typical household.  These bills, alone, will already see most people struggling more than this time last year.

There are other measures that will likely appeal to the public, but, again, their impact will likely be limited by other factors.  The National Living Wage will rise by 102 pence per hour to £11.44 in April, when Universal Credit will also rise by 6.7%, in line with inflation rate from September, alongside an 8.5% increase in the state pension, in accordance with average earnings.  As can be assessed by the qualifying statement at the end of each policy, most boosts in pay packets or cuts to tax bills are simply tied to the price rises of the last eighteen months, meaning the benefit remains, proportionally, the same, when taking the CPI inflation rate into account.  Remember, the inflation rate is slowing, but prices are still rising at a rate nearly triple the standard target of 2%.  So when these policies are announced in a manner which appears to be of great support to the public, it is only right to question if this was an Autumn Statement with a looming general election in mind.

When these policies are announced in a manner which appears to be of great support to the public, it is only right to question if this was an Autumn Statement with a looming general election in mind

This is being argued by many commentators, including Martin Lewis, the famous ‘Money Saving Expert’.  Most economists and forums have welcomed the announcements, but they point to the revised growth rates, as well as the high inflation rate, which will impede the efficacy of the policies.  Lewis takes an even more cynical view, pointing to the Chancellor taking the unusual decision to implement the National Insurance cut in January, rather than April.  He believes this has been done so that when the average person looks at their finances at the end of January, they may be better off than twelve months prior, which would be a good way for the government to begin any year, not least an election year.  But by April, despite the aforementioned minimum wage and benefits rises, this will likely not be the case, and if people are worse off, the government could look at further tax cuts in the Spring Budget, to appease voters.

The fact is, despite its appearance, this Autumn Statement is unlikely to go far enough to significantly improve the livelihoods of people. The OBR estimates that living standards, measured by real household disposable income per person, will be 3.5% lower than pre-pandemic levels, and will not return to the 2019 figure until 2027.  And as long as people do not see more money in their pockets, the government will continue to struggle to win them over, ahead of a crucial election year.

The legacy of this Autumn Statement will become much clearer in the coming months, and by the time the Budget arrives in April, the true success of many of these policies will be obvious

There were, however, some measures announced by Hunt, which could be maintained by any future government, irrespective of the election result in the next year or so.  Other significant tax cuts, taking the overall cost of cuts in the statement to about £20 billion over the next five years, were offered to businesses, big and small.  The headline here was the decision to permanently implement a tax break on profits for companies spending on capital and labour, to encourage long-term business investment in Britain.

This is a policy Labour has refused to rule out maintaining, should the party find itself in power, and with specific measures announced for green businesses, this is understandable.  And it could be argued the benefit of this policy has been seen almost immediately, and not too far from Durham.  On Friday, Nissan announced a £2 billion investment in its manufacturing site in Sunderland, and, as the biggest car plant in the UK, employing over 6,000 people, this is a great example of why this policy has been enforced.  Meanwhile, small businesses will be encouraged by the extension of the 75% discount for hospitality and retail for another year, allowing owners to direct any income towards high energy bills and growing staff wages, rather than the public purse.  These policies suggest that, irrespective of the state of the economy, the Chancellor is doing his best to keep his promise of being on the side of business.

Ultimately, the legacy of this Autumn Statement will become much clearer in the coming months, and by the time the Budget arrives in April, the true success of many of these policies will be obvious.  However, it is evident that, for all the Conservative enthusiasm about the economic recovery since last October, the impact of this will not be felt by the British people, for now anyways.  The announcements made by Hunt last Wednesday were largely positive, but for all the wage rises and tax cuts promised to people in the next few months, these are set against the high inflation and low growth, and will not help the majority of ordinary people.  As a result, these policies appear to be talking points and empty handouts, in a year where the Conservatives need to change the course of public opinion ahead of a general election.  

Image: HM Treasury via Flickr