Brexit: seven years on
By James Nolan
“The British people have spoken, and the answer is – we’re out”. These were the words which echoed across the land, through our airwaves and TV screens, as David Dimbleby addressed the nation, seven years to the day. The pollsters: wrong. The Prime Minister: gone. After 43 years of membership, a 52% majority of people in Britain had voted to leave the European Union.
The following three years were characterised by Tory infighting, as the government wrangled over the details of the deal. The right of the party sought to undermine Theresa May, and the deal she negotiated with Brussels, believing the country needed a Prime Minister who voted Leave. Enter Boris Johnson. In July 2019, and just five months later, he led the Conservatives to an 80-seat majority at the general election, with a clear campaign message: ‘get Brexit done’. On the 31st January 2020, Britain officially withdrew from the EU.
No single issue in modern British history has proved so divisive. Many commentators are still seeking to establish the motive for voting Leave in 2016, as the concepts of sovereignty and taking back control are as broad as they appear. Other analysts are reviewing the period between the referendum and the completion of the Article 50 process, and how the weaknesses of May culminated in the inevitable emergence of Johnson, and the landslide election win and Brexit deal which followed. However, without doubt, most of the Brexit debate is now firmly on the question always destined to be asked after a handful of years: is Brexit delivering for the British people?
“The British people have spoken, and the answer is – we’re out”.
Seven years on from the referendum, the answer appears to be no. Possibly the most notable consequence of Brexit has been leaving the EU single market and customs union, an act which was finalised in January 2021. This ended free trade between Britain and continental Europe, piling red tape on businesses, in the form of extra regulation, checks, and paperwork. Whilst the volume of goods and services traded has recovered to pre-pandemic levels, the costs of both importing and exporting for British businesses have risen, with many being forced to absorb part of these costs, with the rest passed on to the consumer. Multiple global economic forums state that Britain is the only country in the G7 to not have seen a notable increase in trade volumes in the last 18 months, and the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development confirms that Britain is the least liberalised trading economy in the group, as well. It is a similar story with regards to business investment, as Bank of England officials stated in February that £29bn worth of investment had been lost since 2016. Given business investment accounts for as much as 10% of our national GDP, it is little wonder the Centre for European Reform estimates this figure is 5.5% lower than it would have been had Britain not left the EU.
This is just the tip of the Brexit iceberg. However, it is important to hone in on the economic impact of Brexit, now more than ever, due to the cost of living crisis. Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, and Rishi Sunak have all reminded us over the last 18 months that COVID and Ukraine are the reason we are all poorer, not Brexit. But why then, is Britain, a country less reliant on Russian gas than many of our European counterparts, in a far worse position than these countries? Why is inflation higher? The answer, again, returns to trade. Due to the weakness of the Pound since Brexit, and the costs of checks and regulation, importing goods from Europe, and worldwide, has become more expensive for Britain than any other major global economy. The higher costs result in enhanced price shocks for consumers, and the stubbornly high rate of inflation Britain is currently struggling against. There is no indication of an improvement to the economic situation as of yet. This week, the inflation rate for May was confirmed as 8.7%, a figure higher than forecast a few months back, and much higher than is being experienced in mainland Europe. The Bank of England responded by hiking interest rates up by another 0.5%, to 5%, causing uncertainty for those coming to the end of fixed-term mortgages, adding to the cost of living strain for millions of people.
Inflation will remain high because Britain has no solution to the trade issue. The government promised the most extensive ever trade deal with America after leaving the EU, but just a couple of weeks ago, Sunak returned from the White House with the Atlantic Declaration, which is currently very limited in terms of detail, and falls well short of the promise made to the British people. This can be added to the Northern Ireland Protocol, the record immigration figures, and the £350m a week for our NHS as the promises not kept by the Brexit campaign. Those who led the Leave campaign were correct to highlight the new trade deals we could make all over the world as an advantage of Brexit. However, they are now confronted with the uncomfortable truth. No country owes Britain a living, and, post-Brexit, no country is willing to offer their business to our floundering economy in any meaningful capacity.
This is the crux of Brexit. In theory, the themes of sovereignty, “taking back control” and following British law, and British law only, sound reasonable enough. However, the globalised 21st-century world we live in means the reality is very different. With Brexit, Britain has removed itself from a functioning trade relationship with the rest of Europe, in pursuit of something better.
In theory, the themes of sovereignty, “taking back control” and following British law, and British law only, sound reasonable enough.
After any analysis of the impact of Brexit, the question of whether or not Britain would still vote Leave often follows. However, with neither the Conservatives, nor Labour, currently leaving the door open to the prospect of rejoining the EU, this question is only relevant when discussing the approach the parties should be taking towards resolving the issues of Brexit. It is difficult to see how either would go about this, as both Mr Sunak and Sir Keir are doing everything within their power to avoid Brexit being central to discussions ahead of the next election. Mr Sunak, as a Brexiteer and former banker, is intent on avoiding the inevitable questions about the link between Brexit and the cost of living, and how a policy he fervently believes in has hurt the pockets of the British public. Meanwhile, Sir Keir has clearly made a calculated judgement to leave the divisive issue of Brexit to one side, instead focusing on the many other issues the current government has failed to legislate against.
For Labour, this is a risk. Primarily, because Brexit is possibly the most premeditated Conservative policy impacting the cost of living right now. The Tories may be blamed for their responses to the economic problems presented by COVID and Ukraine, but of course not the events themselves. Brexit, however, was instigated, delivered, and applied by the Conservatives, and is without question adding to the cost of living strain. As a result, it is surprising that Labour are not making more of a point about the government failure to execute Brexit in an efficient manner. With YouGov polls from last month indicating only 9% of people believe Brexit has been a success, and a separate Savanta poll suggesting nearly 70% of people would like another referendum in their lifetime, it is clear that Labour could do more to scrutinise the Conservatives on Brexit. Both Mr Sunak and Sir Keir are too afraid of stepping on an electoral landmine to provide a decisive plan on how the next Conservative or Labour government would limit the impact of Brexit on the nation. Brexit has failed the British people, and we need those in power in Westminster to front up to this fact.
For now, Brexit remains an economic disaster, felt in the bank balances of the biggest businesses, and the pockets of working Britons alike. And where exactly we go from here is unclear. The cost of living crisis will eventually ease, with the stabilisation of global energy prices, but Britain will keep lagging behind the other major economies of Europe and the world, until decisive action is taken on Brexit. We need trade deals, vacancies filled, and an end to sky high inflation. But before this, we need to reach a national consensus that Britain will never succeed without close ties with Europe. Even if this does not mean rejoining the EU, we need a return to diplomacy, and a clear plan to reintegrate Britain into a workable relationship with Europe over the exchange of goods and services, capital, and labour. We may be physically removed from continental Europe, but Britain as an economic island in the global 21st-century benefits no one. Mr Sunak and Sir Keir can try as they like, but the British people cannot, and will not, accept silence over Brexit forever.
Image: via Wallpaper Flare
