Human sense of smell more powerful than previously thought

By Vicky Smith smell600x400

We may regard smell as a somewhat second-rate sense compared to vision or hearing, but new research shows that it may actually be our most sensitive sense.

Scientists believe that humans can discriminate between half a million different tones and several million different colours, however this seems to be relatively unimpressive compared to the one trillion odours they now think we can distinguish.

This figure of one trillion, never before estimated, was calculated by Dr Andreas Keller and his colleagues at the Rockefeller University in New York.

Twenty-six volunteers, with no experience in analysing smells, were presented with three vials containing combinations of ten, twenty or thirty out of a total of 128 compounds, including those evoking smells of: citrus, spearmint, grass and orange. The task was to spot the ‘odd one out’, which was the jar with a different molecular makeup to the remaining two jars.

Their results, reported in the journal Science, showed that on average the experimenters could successfully identify the unique jar when at least half of the molecules were different.

By an extrapolation of the number of different combinations of the 128 compounds the volunteers could tell apart, the number one trillion was reached. However, the estimated distinguishing ability ranged from 80 million to more than 100 trillion scents.

Humans also have the ability to detect many of these scent compounds at minute concentrations. For example the compound added to natural gas to help detect gas leaks can be sensed at a concentration of less that 0.0003 parts per million.

Smell is a sense that should in no way be overlooked

From these findings, our sense of smell is not thought to be much closer to that of animals than was previously believed. Nevertheless, our noses are not nearly as sensitive as those of many other animals whose wellbeing depends on interpreting olfactory cues; for example, dogs have between 125 and 300 million scent glands in their noses compared to our five million.

In addition, the extension of the forebrain that receives input from the primary olfactory neurons, the olfactory bulb, is much better developed in vertebrates other than humans since their survival is more closely linked to chemical monitoring of their surroundings.

Scientists believe that smell has gradually become a less important sense to human beings since our upright posture has positioned our noses further away from the ground, the source of many smells linked to our wellbeing, such as those from dangerous animals or edible plants.

Moreover, many smells are now masked by perfumes, air fresheners and deodorants, meaning that we are no longer constantly exposed to the smells that were once strongly connected to our chances of survival.

Dr Andreas Keller said: ‘the message here is that we have more sensitivity in our sense of smell than … we give ourselves credit for. We just don’t pay attention to it and don’t use it in everyday life.’

Smell is a sense that should in no way be overlooked because it is the only sense with pathways that are directly connected to the forebrain, which is responsible for complex cognitive, emotional, sensory and motor functions.

Olfactory pathways enter the brain at the frontal lobe and the amygdala, which is a part of the brain that plays a central role in many emotional processes, including the formation of emotional memories. By some as yet unknown mechanism, the processing of odours through forebrain structures creates deeply buried olfactory memories.

In rodents, an accessory olfactory structure called the vomeronasal organ (VNO), found in the nasal cavity, is known to be involved in behavioural responses to sex pheromones, which are chemicals emitted in unique combinations from sweat glands.

Anatomical studies in humans have yet to find clear evidence for or against a functional human VNO, but experiments with compounds believed to act as human pheromones indicate that humans communicate via these chemical signals and the compounds may even be involved in physical attraction and mate selection.

The study at the Rockefeller’s Laboratory of Neurogenetics, testing combinations of ten, twenty or thirty scent compounds on volunteers, has focussed scientist’s attention on how complex combinations of smells are sensed and processed. This is an important factor in our understanding of the olfactory system since even chocolate, with its recognisable scent that we may expect to be simple, is composed of over 600 of discrete odour molecules.

The relationship between smell, memory and emotion is a fascinating yet poorly understood aspect of olfaction. The activation of particular combinations of olfactory receptors by the presence of particular scent combinations somehow leads to unique sensory effects, such as a particular cologne evoking memories of a figure from our childhood.

This study has led the way for further research into the processing of complex smells and the mechanisms linking behaviour, memory, emotion and the olfactory system.

Photograph: Savannah Lewis on Flickr