Has democracy taken a bad hit in Honduras?

At dawn on June 28th 2009 armed forces broke into Honduran president Manuel Zelaya’s house, dragged him out of bed to the airport and placed him on a plane to San José, Costa Rica. The Honduran capital, Tegucigalpa, was patrolled by military tanks, and electricity supplies to the city were cut. Television was prevented from giving any news on the events, and one station was silenced completely.
This type of military coup, once common in Latin America, has recently been in decline due to the moderate success of democracy throughout the continent, Honduras itself with one of the most stable and functioning democratic systems.
The coup, therefore, came as a complete international surprise, especially given the amount of support it seemed to have. This was not just a military operation, it was sanctioned by Congress and apparently by the people, thousands of whom celebrated the removal of Zelaya by filling Tegucigalpa’s main square on June 30th.
Zelaya’s presidency was marked by a rise in corruption and crime. Originally a liberal politician, his popularity has been steadily falling since he made moves towards the extreme left, allying himself with Venezuelan populist president Hugo Chávez and borrowing money from Venezuela in times of economic need.
The events of his fall occurred as he tried to push through a consultative poll, which would allow elections in November to vote on calling a constituent assembly. It seems that the aim of this would be to change the constitution so that Zelaya would be able to remain in power for a second term, currently unconstitutional in Honduras. When the head of the military refused to hand out ballot papers for the poll and Zelaya fired him, Congress carried out their military arrest.
Zelaya’s constitutional amendment attempts are reminiscent of other sinister incidents involving ‘elections’ which allow people to vote their leader into power indefinitely; a key example of this being Hugo Chávez’ reformation of the Venezuelan constitution in 1999. Honduras, a politically liberal but generally conservative country, did not want steps towards dictatorships.
Zelaya has been replaced by Head of Congress Roberto Micheletti who claims that the reasoning behind removing Zelaya is due to the fact that his actions defied the Supreme Court and the constitution. The new government is calling the coup a ‘constitutional succession’ although it is not internationally recognized. The UN has declared the incident ‘illegal’ and not one country has acknowledged Micheletti’s administration as legitimate, despite Zelaya’s unpopularity and moves towards authoritarianism.
The USA’s reaction to the situation has been interesting. In a bid to get away from the politics of his predecessor, Obama has condemned the coup despite Zelaya’s growing socialist sympathies. George W Bush, contrastingly, had CIA intelligence of a plot regarding a coup against Hugo Chávez in 2002 and notably did nothing about it. Obama’s reaction has bewildered Chávez who was looking to blame the USA for the events.
Costa Rican president Óscar Arias seems to have come up with the most sensible solution to diffuse the situation, but negotiations so far have been unsuccessful. He wishes to see Zelaya reinstated as president, but not be allowed to extend his term past November. There will be no official political party of Honduras during the months before the election but instead a government composed of all parties, and Zelaya will be internationally supervised.
The problem with this solution is that both sides are unwilling to compromise. Zelaya wants to remain in power until January, and Micheletti will not have him back as president at all. This stalemate is causing diplomatic tensions to rise every day.
The events occurring since the coup have not made the situation any easier to diffuse. Again parodying Chávez, Zelaya returned to Honduras on September 21st from neighbouring Nicaragua in an attempt to regain power. He believed that once he was back in the country a wave of popular support would carry him back into presidency.
This turned out to be misguided, as Micheletti simply placed a militarily enforced 60-plus hour curfew on the people of Honduras. The Brazilian embassy, where Zelaya had returned and made several inflammatory speeches from, had its water and electrical supplies cut. Any supporters of Zelaya who came out to protest were shot at with rubber bullets and tear-gassed until they dispersed. Hospitals recorded treating 83 people for injuries and one person died.
Do the Honduran people and the interim government have a right to be scared that once restored Zelaya will never leave power? There is argument on both sides here, whilst this undoubtedly is what Mr Zelaya wants there has been little indication that his attempt at reform would have been successful. Zelaya was unpopular and other countries in Latin America, such as Argentina, have been curbing power of dominant political leaders, demonstrating that authoritarian hold on power is crumbling in the region, Chávez being the notable exception.
Another reason in favour of Arias’ solution of temporarily reinstating Zelaya comes from the actions of Micheletti as he exposes himself as authoritarian and militant. On September 26th he used the military to shut down television in support of Zelaya and has imposed a nationwide curfew. Initially meant to last 48 hours during Zelaya’s ousting to prevent civil unrest, it has since continued indefinitely, with citizens confined to their houses past 1am. He has also threatened the Brazilian embassy with unnamed consequences for their affiliation with Zelaya. These are not the actions of a government in power, temporarily to look after the constitutional rights of the people.
International condemnation for the Micheletti administration has isolated Honduras politically and economically. As well as Hugo Chávez’ threatened invasion of the country, foreign aid equivalent to 6% of the GDP has been cut. The USA has stopped all non-humanitarian aid to the country and has suspended Honduras from the Organization of American States.
In the 48 hours following the coup Honduras’ neighbours Nicaragua, Guatemala and El Salvador halted trade with the country, resulting in a national loss of sixteen million US dollars. The worry for Honduras is that the next stage will be a reinstatement of these trade embargoes, with an additional halving in trade from the USA. As Honduras relies almost entirely on trade with its Latin American neighbours and the US this would result in a severe economic crisis in a country already suffering from corruption and poverty.
So what should be done? As ongoing trade embargoes would be economically devastating for Honduras, if Obama enforced them the interim government would have no choice but to compromise. Micheletti has no international support and Honduras does not have the finances or resources to become self-sufficient. If the threat of economic crisis coerced Micheletti and Zelaya into accepting the terms that Arias had suggested surely this would be a positive outcome?
President Obama has come under criticism, in particular from the Brazilians, for not putting more pressure on the Micheletti regime, especially when his influence could completely change, or perhaps even resolve the situation. The Honduran people need free and fair elections in order to allow them to choose a government they want, but threatening the country with economic crisis smacks of US imperialism.
However, as elections are due to be held November 26th and diplomatic negotiations are currently in stalemate time, it seems options are running out fast.