Dan Hannan was right: the NHS has been a 60-year mistake

Healthcare is one of those emotive political issues where it seem impossible to reach any sort of consensus. In the States, we have protesters turning out in their thousands to oppose Obama’s minor reforms; in Britain, we have a Conservative MEP vilified for daring to criticize how things are run in this country. And though in such situations it is tempting to look for a third way, it this case it is clear that the “unpatriotic” Hannan has things about right: the NHS has indeed been a sixty-year mistake.
In the summer of 2007, fresh from school, I started work in the finance department of a Primary Care Trust. Although I had little experience of business, the callous attitude to money I saw there appalled me. Thousands of pounds had been paid in error to temp agencies, because managers signed any old invoice put in front of them. Millions wasted on new health centres, when there were dozens of perfectly serviceable doctors’ surgeries in the areas. And, most ludicrously of all, the frantic struggle at the end of the financial year to spend all the money remaining in the central bank account; if any had been left over, the trust would have been penalized.
In the 1970s, the Government proved that it could not run the car industry: it simply could not achieve the same efficiency as private enterprise. For the NHS, this lack of efficiency is manifested not in shoddy Rovers but in botched operations and MRSA infections. As anyone who has seen Yes, Minister will know, all government initiatives are run for the benefit of the politicians and the bureaucrats rather than the general public. A poor car manufacturer will quickly goes bust when no one buys his products, but with elections only every five years, government schemes will never be able to fully meet the needs of the public.
Nor is it possible to control policy in any meaningful way. Sarah Palin’s talk of Obama’s “death panels” may have been a touch hyperbolic, but that is at heart what the euphemistically named quango NICE is. It decides how much of the healthcare budget can be spent on which drugs: patients may have spent their whole lives paying for the NHS through their taxes, but they have no say on which drugs they may or may not be given. Until very recently, if patients bought drugs with their own money, they would be barred from NHS treatment altogether. In an insurance-based system, competition ensures that cancer sufferers aren’t left to die through the whim of an unelected bureaucrat.
Quite apart from all this, the pernicious effects of socialized medicine upon society cannot be ignored. When healthcare comes to be seen as a human right, no one will taken any responsibility for either it or their own wellbeing. Doctors’ timetables are full of appointments booked “just in case”. And would there really be quite so many drunks brawling on a Saturday night, if they knew that they would be personally out of pocket for any injuries they sustained?
Do not neglect either the influence the NHS has upon the growth of the nanny state. By all rights, the Government ought not to give a hoot about public health, save perhaps for infectious diseases. If I want to eat my way to an early grave, or pickle my liver, I may be stupid, but it is no one’s concern but mine. But when the cost is borne by all, the responsibility is borne by all: we have all become each other’s slaves. It is little wonder that politicians were so eager to endorse Jamie Oliver’s anti-chip crusade: it was done not out of altruism, but from economic necessity. Once you start to limit economic freedom, so you must also limit social freedom, or else go bankrupt. In the days when Marshall Aid was plentiful, and the budget deficit wasn’t something that kept George Osborne awake at night, that might have been less of a concern; but in 2009, the British people deserve better.
So, what is to be done? Like most outstanding political problems, there is no one answer. At the moment, we have a system where the individual has effectively no control over either how much healthcare costs him, or what services it provides. The obvious advantage to this is that no-one is turned away due to lack of means. If I may channel Palin for a moment, it is reminiscent of the bread-queues in the old USSR: no-one starved, but no-one had enough to eat either. The opposite to this, with the poor relying solely on private charity, might very well lead to the return of such childhood diseases as polio and tuberculosis. There is obviously a balance to be made between the two extremes. With a Conservative government very likely to be elected in a little under seven months, now is the time for Mr. Cameron to set out his vision for how Britain’s health service ought to look.