Has Covid-19 caused the death of satire?
By Samuel Lopes
Satire seems to flourish when things are going fairly well in the grand scheme of things. The issues of the day must be large enough to be important, and yet understandable enough to be easily susceptible to mockery. At its best, satire is irony and sardonicism that is weaponised, targeting those in power – but it has to hurt. Good satire fosters, if not a public, then a perceived sense of shame by those on the receiving end of such satirical criticism.
What happens, then, when conventional satire and cold hard reality collide? Does satire still have a place in a post-coronavirus world?
Lately, satire appears to be bleeding into reality.
There has been a proud tradition of modern political satire in the UK stemming from the 1980s to the present day. Programmes such as Yes, Minister, Spitting Image and The Thick of It have all satirised various aspects of political life over the past thirty years. Lately, however, satire appears to be bleeding into reality.
Even Armando Iannucci, the creator of some of the best satire of recent times, published an article in October of last year following Trump contracting Covid-19, entitled, ‘I Created Veep and Even I Couldn’t Make the Last Week Up’. When asked whether he could effectively satirise Trump, he responded, “I’d find it very difficult to do fiction set in the world of government while what’s happening in reality is far more absurd”.
Even our own Prime Minister has surpassed satirical criticism. Many populist figures have incorporated satirised versions of themselves into their political personas – creating an ideological vaccine against criticism by constructing political narratives far removed from reality. This has the negative effect of allowing real political failings to slip through the cracks. Take the overwhelming level of cronyism that has been allowed to festerin Britain over the course of the pandemic, resulting in the squandering of vast amounts of taxpayer money.
Nearly £2 billion of Covid-19 contracts went to those with connections to the Conservative Party. Sadly, this is now expected by many as a result of Johnson’s ‘boys-club’ Etonian personality, with polling figures remaining relatively unchanged since November.
A basic level of competence, thankfully (and finally) seen in the rollout of vaccinations, exceeds public expectations of the government.
Such collisions of farce with reality are not just limited to national government.
Such collisions of farce with reality are not just limited to national government. In the seventeen-minute clip of the Handforth Parish Council meeting published online last week, the nation collectively saw the impotent rage of several middleaged men explode over whether Jackie Weaver had the authority to call an extraordinary (in all senses of the word) meeting of the parish council.
The response from the public was swift, with some calling it, “the best British comedy in decades”. The tumultuous events of the past few years (as well as the current trilogy of lockdowns) have made our old points of reference obsolete. Faced with a lack of social stimulation, many have chosen to retreat into their inner lives and thus common social grievances have become all-consuming.
Perhaps this is what prompted the violent and disproportionate outbursts by the councillors of Handforth. In the face of this virus, comfort can be gleaned from that which seems unchanging, like reading and understanding the standing orders in the memorable words of ‘Aled’s iPad’.
It is difficult to effectively satirise events which, to many, already seem farcical or fantastical. Besides, one must recognise the great struggles that many are continuing to undergo as we struggle through the third wave of the virus. Maybe now is not the time for satire. But we shouldn’t underestimate the power of satirical commentary to hold our elected leaders to account.
Treating important and prescient issues by responding with satire can be an important tool in highlighting the immoral or incompetent. Satire, in contrast to popular belief, is not dead – but perhaps it should be adapted, in light of the current pandemic, so it can perform its vital political role once more.
Image: DonkeyHotey via Creative Commons

