Gerhard Richter: What art thou worth?
In recent years the art world has more than once dipped its feet into the pool of popular culture, causing ripples of division. The divisive question, to which people tend to answer intuitively, is this: Can a piece of art really be worth tens of millions of pounds? Earlier this year an abstract painting, ‘Abstraktes Bild’, by Gerhard Richter sold at Sotheby’s for the rather juicy sum of £21.3m, beating his previous record of $21.8m and setting a new record for the price paid at auction for the work of a living artist. Regardless of the fact that, since the death of Lucien Freud, Richter is widely acknowledged as the greatest living painter today, it was a startling turn out for the books for even the most seasoned, bushy-eyebrowed, auction-goer.
It’s not the only record set this year, however. You will remember Edvard Munch’s ‘The Scream’ going under the hammer at Sotherby’s for $107m ($119.9m after the buyer’s premium) and setting a record for any work of art ever sold at auction. In 2010 it was Picasso’s Nude, ‘Green Leaves and Bust’, at $106 and let us not forget Damien Hirst and his Midas touch with an estimated personal wealth of £215m. The question rises again; can the works of these artists really be worth the cash? My reply is … well, yes!
Primarily, it is worth remembering that art is not a utility commodity like a pitchfork or an iPod. Quintessentially its worth does not evoke a consideration of the materials used, the time taken, though of course, much like an iPod, the designer’s reputation invariably comes into play (for Eric Clapton, who sold the Richter piece, the artist’s reputation had virtually guaranteed a sound investment). The artworks themselves are ‘useless’, ‘purposeless’, as commodities in every role other than sense provocation. This is an idea that dates back to Immanuel Kant and his Critique of Aesthetic Judgement. Importantly, then, the worth of a piece of art must rest upon something other than the price of its constituent parts (its worth must be a consideration external to the work itself). It is here that I believe the good old phrase ‘Beauty is in the eye of the beholder’ comes into play.
But £20 million, £100 million?! Surely these figures are ridiculous. I don’t think so at all. Anyone that is prepared to spend two hundred pounds on a watch instead of ten for aesthetic reasons might be subject to questioning of a similar vein. The criteria for criticisms of this sort are the same whether the object of discussion has been bought for a thousand pounds or a tenner; it is merely a matter of relativity. Of course, there will be those that say that $120m spent on anything that is not ‘useful’ is ridiculous. Again I find myself in disagreement. The greatest things in life are not those that are classically deemed ‘useful’: I’m thinking about the things that evoke joy, happiness, a sense of fulfilment; anything from sport to a relationship. Art, beautiful or otherwise, is a crucial and vibrant flavour in the rich tapestry of life. It has the power to enrich our existence, enabling us to, as the writer Thomas Merton said, ‘find ourselves and lose ourselves at the same time’. To ignore art, be it visual, music, or literature, is to ignore a huge facet of what makes us human; the capacity to express.
For as long as there are individuals with this attitude to art and money in the bank, the worth of a painting is in the eye of the beholder. £120m for something useful like a washing machine… madness… but for a painting? I, for one, am on board.
Photograph: The Telegraph

