From Terreur to Solidarité – in the midst of an extraordinary week in Paris
By Charles Hudson
PARIS – ‘L’amour plus fort que la haine’- ‘Love is stronger than hate’ is a slogan which has defined the response to the recent terrorist attacks on the French capital – and it is a mindset that I have seen in practice many times in the last week. There is no doubt that the atmosphere has been tenser than normal but Parisians have also come out with an unprecedented display of warmth and tolerance.
Going abroad for a year necessarily throws you into contact with the unexpected at every turn. What could be further from Durham than Paris’ elegant café culture, vibrant music scene, or the throngs of shoppers on the Champs-Élysées? The rhythm of the continental big-city beats at a faster rate than in the Durham bubble and one has the impression that nothing could dent the pace of life here.
That said, the events of last week which began on Wednesday morning were a shock to all those who live and work in the capital. As news stories developed throughout the morning of the massacre at the satirical weekly Charlie Hebdo and the death toll rose, there was disbelief among those around me that such a bloody attack could happen in broad daylight in the heart of Paris.
The following morning the city woke up to face the implementation of the highest possible threat warning level. Posters appeared on civic buildings informing the public of the risk of further attacks, and there was a noticeable military presence at transport interchanges and landmarks. I was in the south of Paris and saw a convoy of armoured vehicles and balaclava-clad police rushing towards the suburbs. I later discovered that this was a response to another attack, this time the killing of police officer Clarissa Jean-Philippe in Montrouge, south of the city centre. I saw an even greater police presence on Friday near to Place de la Nation, as another hostage situation unfolded at a kosher supermarket in the east of the city. Sirens could be heard all around and it was a surreal sight to see armed police on every street corner.
At the same time Parisian life has gone on as normal in the midst of these events which have made headlines worldwide. Only a few blocks away from the hostage situation unfolding near the Porte de Vincennes, I saw cafés still bustling with the same vitality for which Paris is so well known. While the impression from the press might have been of a city on the edge, the reality is that in most instances life has gone on unperturbed.
Parisians have led the world in showing how to respond to atrocities in a meaningful and inclusive manner. Thursday, the day after the initial attack, was designated a day of national mourning by President François Hollande. I was in a railway station for the minute’s silence at midday and it was extremely moving to see passengers, staff and security forces fall silent in tribute to the victims of the previous day. It only took a day for ‘Je Suis Charlie’ to be plastered on billboards, shop windows and information boards across the city in memory of journalists and policemen killed at the journal’s offices.
The expression of shared trauma was at its most evident in the vigils and gatherings which took place on Place de la République. On the Thursday night, when I went, the atmosphere was one of sadness but also a celebration of freedom of the press. This impression was even stronger at the monumental ‘Marche Républicaine’ on Sunday. The people I spoke to there were immensely emotionally engaged with the whole event. Some focused primarily on the anti-Semitism of the supermarket siege while one woman mourned the murder of a cartoonist whose work had been present with her since childhood – but all were firm in their conviction that a mass display of solidarity was a fitting riposte to those who sought to tear French society apart. The culmination of the march at Place de la Nation was particularly impressive as more banners were unfurled and ‘Je Suis Charlie’ rang out around the square. I’ve been a Charlie my whole life but to feel united against violence with so many other people, whatever one’s stance on controversial cartoons, was genuinely awe inspiring.
Overall, the powerful response to these awful events has been heralded around the world as an example of unity at a time of crisis, and my experience reflects this. The placards at the march displayed compassion and wit against the threat of terror. Then again, there are still security concerns, demonstrated, for example, by the round the clock armed police presence at the offices of Le Canard Enchainé, another satirical weekly, across the street from my flat. Moreover, questions remain over the longevity of the solidarity which Paris found last week, in a country where the extent of the freedom of the press and the place of Islam in the national identity have been hotly debated for years.
Photographs: Charlie Hudson


