Flood defences did not fail because of spending on foreign aid

By Hannah Watson

Storm Eva brought the residents of York a late and unwanted Christmas present that none of us were expecting this year. As both of York’s rivers, the Ouse and the Foss, broke their banks, 500 homes were evacuated and the army was sent in to aid locals with the distribution of sandbags and to evacuate to safety.

Having spent the last five days trapped between the floodwater that has blocked each end of my road – a few minutes’ walk south of the city centre – I can safely say that what I have found most disturbing about the events of the last week has been the blame game that has followed. Much of the right-wing press and social media have been dominated by accusations of a lack of government funding for the failure of adequate flood defences due to the amount spent on foreign aid. The Telegraph asked the question “why should British taxpayers continue to pay for flood defences abroad when the money is needed here?” while Conservative MP Owen Paterson argued “It must be a priority to spend British taxpayers’ money on British citizens who are suffering.”

However, far less has been said about the main reason why the flooding in York has been so serious this year. Following two major storms – Storm Desmond which hit the UK on 5th December and Storm Eva which followed on 23rd – the flood defences struggled to cope with the unusually high river levels, despite having successfully defended the city against annual floods since 2000. The failure of the Foss barrier and the Environment Agency’s decision not to lower it resulted in parts of the city being affected that are usually spared. As such, they were unprepared for the events of the last few days.

The effects of this have been difficult with businesses closing, damage to hundreds of homes, tourist attractions such as the Jorvik Viking Centre being submerged and the inevitable millions of pounds that will be spent on the clear-up. In comparison my own experiences are trivial but frustrating: I have been isolated from all of my friends who live in different parts of the city and have struggled with a loss of Wi-Fi and phone signal for days.

We need to put this into context – nobody in York has died, and the impact on the city has been minimal in comparison to the damage created in developing countries that can only provide limited flood defences with their lack of financial resources. Many social media users have questioned why Myanmar has received £4 million in aid for flooding problems while people are suffering in the UK. But the floods that hit an unprepared Myanmar in August 2015 resulted in over one hundred deaths and the loss of livelihoods for many as over one million acres of rice fields were destroyed. Due to a lack of funds, the recovery will be far slower than we will see in York, where clean-up efforts are already beginning as the water levels recede.

Responding to the media outrage about the cost of foreign aid, actor Michael Sheen said, “I think it’s a false argument, I don’t think it’s an either-or…I’m completely sick… of ideological agendas, using very real issues that affect ordinary people in this country and abroad, as a political football.” One Twitter user replied, “I dare him to say that in waterlogged York.”

As a York resident who has got her feet very wet this past week, I fully accept and agree with Sheen’s comments. Taxpayers’ money should be spent on those who need it, both in our country but also in other countries that do not have the ability to develop flood defences that are as strong and effective as ours are, the majority of the time. We cannot prevent every single flood from occurring and we cannot stop every single home and business from being damaged. And while questions need to be asked about whether more can be done to prevent this kind of damage, the attention and blame should not be directed towards other countries who suffer equally, if not more, than us when it comes to natural disasters.

It should instead be turned to the government, and whether it can really justify the cuts that have been made to flood defences over the last five years, resulting in the suspension of flood defence projects across Yorkshire. This included the suspension of a £180 million project in Leeds, where over 2000 homes have been damaged in the last few days. It seems to me that if we are looking to hold anybody responsible for the extent of the damage from the recent floods, perhaps it is to here that our attention should first be turned. It is very convenient, of course, to blame support for the poor and the desperate in other countries for a lack of support in our own. This is false logic at its worst and an abject denial of any government’s first responsibility – to look after the security of its people. If it takes our Christmas floods to make this point, then at least some of the cost, suffering and inconvenience might have been worth it.

Photograph: Matthew Hatton via geograph.org.uk