Aladdin vs Beauty: Luther or The Bridge

by Adam Cunnane

Long gone now are the days in which one of the highlights of my festive period was watching a pantomime. Snuggled up against the red upholstery of the Stockport Plaza, I remember the ardent anticipation before the unveiling of the curtain, the arrival of the characters on stage, and the beginning of the show.

Unusually, for the first time in a long while, I got to watch another pantomime this year, in the form of Luther. Sure, there is a bit less arbitrary murder of random, kind individuals (think the clichĂ©s of kind elderly people, loving families with apathetic teenagers) in say – Aladdin – but the comparison stands. Everything, as with a pantomime, was exaggerated; the violence, as befits the demands of those who need constant threat and action to arrest their attention, was gratuitous and meted out in generous portions. Luther is so divorced from reality, so cartoonish, that it struggles to transcend the pantomime genre. It is difficult to empathise with a situation likely conjured by writers who, apathetic themselves, turn to the most outlandish, meaningless premise they can fathom.

Everything in Luther was slapstick and unbelievable; in one scene, the killer tortures himself for reasons unknown. In another he throws himself into a moving car to slaughter a husband and wife, again for little known motivation. Even the emotions of Luther and his colleague Emma Lane are little developed; John has no time to mourn the death of a friend given he is being chased by every hitman in the city concurrently in a ridiculous side plot (strangely they put little effort into murdering him and are easily dispatched by a trash can and a fire extinguisher). Lane herself acts as a paragon for the police by aspiring to eat the killer’s own heart in one scene.

In contrast, The Bridge is able to benefit from its ten episode run (unlike Luther’s two episodes) to allow the plot and the characters to ferment and brood. It is not afraid to give the audience time to pause, to allow the tension to seep uncontrollably into every moment of brief respite. Sofia Helin, who plays Saga Noren, its tortured lead, is stunning. Without the support of Hans Petterson, her former friend and father-figure, and increasingly bullied by her new supervisor Linn, she struggles to balance the exigencies of her latest case and the belated return of her mother after a long absence. The Bridge wallows in a spectacle of melancholy and provokes empathy and terror in equal measure.

As the unidentified killer takes inspiration from the art collection of Freddie Holst in their calculated rampage, we concurrently learn of the inner demons of all The Bridge’s leads. Thure Lindhardt, addicted to painkillers, is hauntingly tormented by the disappearance of his wife and children, and, of course, there is Saga. The backdrop of her degeneration is the swinging pendulum of the case, as suspects disappear and reappear in the mists of ambiguity, and as the finger of blame constantly shifts.

The Bridge is everything that a good drama should be; following the lives of the suspects, the victims and the police, it is masterful in its evocation of empathy, despair and anguish. Its ending, like the glorious 9 hours that preceded it, was liminal and transient in its resolution. Its final scene brings to mind the Japanese term aware; it is a scene infused with fading, fragile beauty, conjuring the closest thing to intimacy to which Saga and many of us can aspire.