Fertility seminars: women are not just wombs

By Maddie Whitaker

The freshly appointed President at Cambridge University’s Murray Edwards college, Dorothy Byrne, recently announced via an article in The Times her intent to introduce fertility seminars at the college. These will supposedly teach the students to plan to start a family by their mid-30s, unless they want to risk ending up childless. Byrne is concerned that women increasingly “forget to have a baby”, due to being pushed to excel professionally, which she proclaims she herself experienced. 

Murray Edwards College is one of the last three bastions of women’s colleges in the United Kingdom. These students have reached the height of academic rigour. Yet, while this proposal is clearly something Byrne is passionate about, and is one of the first initiatives she has instigated as President, the suggestion that women are ‘forgetting’ to have children is insulting to all women, not just those at Murray Edwards.

One only needs to consider the difference in the lexical meanings between ‘spinster’ and ‘bachelor’, to glean a sense of the cultural expectations placed on women throughout their lives to have children. Women’s fertility is impossible for them to forget. From phrases like ‘ticking biological clock’, to Bridget Jones’ dramatic fertility anxieties, down to how young girls are socialised to care for baby dolls, the cultural canon today consists of fodder which constantly reminds women of the need to have children. 

Byrne’s take on the perception of maternity in frankly baffling

In making this proposal, Byrne is adding to the societal onus put on women, not only that they need to have children, but the expectation it should also dominate their priorities. 

The most dangerous implication from Byrne’s proposal is not that she is endorsing motherhood, but that it intimates to the women of Murray Edwards that while they may have reached the highest echelons of university education, their intellectual achievements are secondary in importance to attaining the ultimate goal — motherhood. 

She also confusingly claims it “has become almost forbidden” to talk about “courting”, or ask women when they plan to have a baby. For this to come from the former head of news at Channel 4 is concerning, as her worldview seems extremely warped. While the word “courting” may not be in the everyday vernacular, women are constantly asked about their dating life, and it was well publicised in 2019 when more people applied to Love Island than Cambridge. 

Byrne’s take on the perception of maternity is frankly baffling. Byrne talks as if most women don’t want to have children, which is blatantly not the case. She further incises that “we have swung too far one way” towards prioritising women’s careers over motherhood. The falling birth rate she evidences this fact with, cannot simply be explained by women not wanting to have children. 

Unfortunately, gendered bias and discrimination persist in professional spheres

Most importantly, the proposed fertility classes ignore that having children isn’t just a personal choice, it is an economic one. Nevertheless, patriarchal societal structures do not invite women to have children in the professional world. 

Unfortunately, gendered bias and discrimination persist in professional spheres. Yet Byrne ignores that the main reason women are having children later is not because they are forgetting, but due to socio-economic factors. 

The fact remains that women’s biological and career clocks do not exist in a happy synchronicity, but as Murray Edwards is an all-women college, the proposed classes inevitably and glaringly leave men out of the equation, despite patriarchal professional structures being the realm where change is most needed. Our society already prohibits women from excelling in their careers. Feminism needs cultural shifts, and we need people in positions of power, like Byrne, to be forcing positive change. 

Ultimately, this screams of a personal and misguided effort, and one can only hope these classes will either be stopped, or that their design undergoes a radical change in tone and structure. Byrne’s proposed classes seem at best obsolete, and at worst a disturbingly dystopian decision to come from one of Cambridge’s colleges.

Image: Cmglee via Creative Commons