Exploring Durham’s £6m utilities bill

by Sally Wardle

Palatinate research has revealed the vast extent of the University’s utility bills.

Durham University records show that in 2011/12, £2,213,812 was spent on the provision of gas, and £4,020,660 on electricity for departments and colleges.

Reacting to these figures, one student commented, “Thousands of pounds must be wasted on unnecessary lighting and heating.”

According to last year’s official gas and electricity report, from August 2011 to June 2012, 9.079,818 kWh of electrical energy were consumed in colleges alone. 1 kWh is enough to heat 20 microwave meals, so the amount of energy consumed was enough to microwave 181,596,360 dinners.

However, this figure did mark an overall 4.25% decrease in electrical energy consumption by colleges from the previous year.

The biggest offender in terms of electrical usage was Ustinov, making up 13.13% of the total figure, followed by Van Mildert at 9.77%.

The Ustinov figure may partly be explained by the longer residence period of postgraduates.

Stephenson College marked a significant improvement from the 2010/2011 period, reducing their use of electricity by 27.84%.

In the consumption of gas, a total of 36,034,313 kWh of energy were consumed by colleges, with the College of St Hild and Bede responsible for 14% of this figure.

“We do of course recognise that a proportion of these figures will be due to unnecessary energy use.”

Kate Ridley, Students and Colleges Sustainability Co-ordinator at the University, responded to these figures:

“We do of course recognise that a proportion of these figures will be due to unnecessary energy use… which is why energy reduction initiatives are so important.”

Ms Ridley argued that “a key determinant for how well a college is performing environmentally is the attitude and behaviour of college members.”

As part of University policy, every college has an elected Student Officer working alongside a Staff Environmental Champion to combat environmental issues. However, Ms Ridley admits that the emphasis put on this role varies between colleges.

“In some colleges the Environment Rep is a JCR Exec member and is supported by a student committee therefore enabling the environmental considerations to be full embedded within all JCR actions.”

This raises a crucial question – do Durham students care enough about their environmental impact?

Living in college, with no immediate financial implications, many students show blatant disregard for their actions. Lights are often left on, and windows open.

Ben Page, a second year Geography student, recognises this problem: “In terms of living in college, from my own experiences the fact that there is no individual cost for energy consumption means people do not care for the amount of energy they use.”

“Those who use significant amount of resources face no punishment.”

He adds, “Those who use significant amount of resources face no punishment.”

However, one second year student, who wished to remain anonymous, suggested that students were not always to blame for such behaviour, stating that colleges “don’t regulate the temperatures in the communal areas or rooms – they’re either freezing or far too hot.”

In response, Kate Ridley highlights the University heating policy “which specifies target temperatures. All students (and staff) can report any energy wastage to energy.awareness@durham.ac.uk.”

Though some students may be unaware, the University does have a comprehensive environmental policy, achieving the Altogether Greener Award for the Green Move Out Scheme, Green Gown Awards for Procurement and the Student Environment Group and Silver and Gold Green Tourism Awards for most colleges.

Similarly, as a member of the Carbon Trust Higher Education Carbon Management programme, the University is attempting to reduce carbon emissions by 30% over the five years to 2013/14,

A report by the University highlights the important of environmental awareness as “over half of the reduction is expected to come from changing the behaviour of staff and students in energy use.”

Since 2008/09, the University has achieved a 6% reduction in carbon emissions, a trend which Ms Ridley argues will continue “as many of the projects implemented come into effect.”

However, compared to other universities, it could be argued that members of Durham University are not doing enough.

In June this year, Durham fell from 41st to 70th in ‘The People & Planet Green League’ which measures the efforts of 145 UK universities to limit their environmental impact.

Whilst Durham scored 29.5 out of 40 for its environmental policy, it scored a meagre 6 out of 30 for environmental performance. This suggests that whilst the University is committed to improving the environment, it is currently not succeeding in practice.

Ben Page was “shocked” by University expenditure on heating and electricity. He feels current university policy is not doing enough to target and engage with students:

“Obviously the University has a wide range of buildings that require heating and lighting.

“However, I think that the £4 million figure can only be justified if the University was trying everything to reduce their costs, and unfortunately I think they are failing on this front.”

 Photograph: Nicoletta Asciuto