Are university-enforced fines fair?

by Chris Bosson

The size and justification of fines for misbehaviour at universities is facing criticism, above all for the use of community service as an alternative disciplinary measure.

A report in The Cambridge Student openly criticised the size and arbitrary nature of many disciplinary fines.

St. John’s College, Cambridge, defended its policy of using community service instead of fines, which are a more common form of punishment for students. The article highlighted that the effect of such punishment differs depending on the individual’s financial position.

Many Durham University colleges employ similar measures, with community service consisting of tasks such as helping set up and clear up after college events, working in college libraries, litter picking, and gardening work. Sentences can range from one to twenty hours.

However, fines are a punishment also employed, alongside more ad-hoc measures such as banning students from areas of college.

The university-wide policy on disciplinary measures is laid out in detail in the statutes and regulations. Offences are identified as either ‘major’ or ‘minor’, according to a set of criteria.

A major offence is one that “does or has the potential to cause serious harm to the University, its staff, and other students.” The Senate Discipline Committee deals with such offences.

The punishment set by the University can range from expulsion, a fine of up to £250, a reduction in degree classification, or other punishments as seen fit.

Usually, colleges and departments handle minor offences.

Authorised University Officers can impose “any punishment […] deemed reasonable” except expulsion, and with a limit of £250 on fines. This freedom in disciplinary measures allows the form of punishments to be appropriate to the offence.

These fines and community service are standardised in most colleges. However, penalties can vary drastically between colleges.

Misconduct at formals and drunken behaviour are amongst the most common sources of punishment.

Throwing up during formal will attract a fine of between £35 at Mary’s and £100 at Hatfield.

Noise offences attract the most arbitrary punishments. Most colleges determine these based on the impact of the disturbance and number of people involved, with fines ranging from £50 – £100 for a small group of students.

Safety-related fines are often the most expensive, an attempt to deter students from engaging in such activity.

Collingwood charges £150 for tampering with, or non-emergency use of, any fire safety equipment, whilst Castle imposes £200 for being found on the roof of the college.

Within the college system, even apparently mundane misbehaviour can result in fines.

Losing or not returning keys to college rooms earns anything from £30 at St. Chad’s, Trevelyan, and Van Mildert, to £60 at Castle.

Remunerative charges are generally made for damage to property, sometimes in addition to fines. When an individual culprit cannot be identified, such charges are often split between students living on a staircase or who attended a particular social.

Some colleges set an additional fine (£100 at Chad’s and Van Mildert) for those who initially do not admit responsibility and yet are later found out to have been the perpetrator.

Speaking of college disciplinary measures, Isabelle Beaudoin, a Castle first year, commented: “Some fines are fair enough, but some, such as the £200 roof charge, are ridiculous.

“It’s true that fines aren’t entirely fair on poorer students, but community service would take up a lot of time that we need for studying. A combination of the two is probably the best system.”

“It’s vital that universities considering levying fines take student hardship into account”

Pete Mercer, vice-president of the NUS, has said: “That institutions are racking up such huge sums in fines suggests that they are gratuitous, and [institutions] are treating students as cash cows. It’s vital that universities considering levying fines take student hardship into account.”

It is not uncommon for groups of people to be disciplined collectively.

The events surrounding the Cuth’s Rugby social, as reported in Palatinate, resulted in £50 fines for all attending members. The organisers were given an additional twenty hours of community service.

The club was also banned from all remaining Cup and league fixtures during Michaelmas term.

Collingwood’s Sportsman’s Ball, which was held at the Radisson in Durham earlier this year, was another incident which required University disciplinary intervention.

Several teams were reported as behaving rowdily. Witnesses claimed plates were thrown around the room and girls were seen writing on the walls with lipstick.

Responsible individuals did not own up to the resulting property damage, meaning all attendees were given an hour of community service. Additionally, all teams were fined based on the number of their members present.

For some, the community service took the form of an hour’s work in Collingwood library, whilst others litter-picked at the Radisson as way of an apology.

A Collingwood student who attended the ball commented: “It’s unfair that people who did nothing wrong have had to pay, but at the same time the damage does need to be paid for.

“If no one owned up, then sharing the cost between those who were there is the fairest way. Punishments in Durham are on the whole quite reasonable compared to some universities, so we can’t complain.”

Photograph: Naomi Ellis