Exam concessions leave dyslexic students at “major disadvantage”
By Becks Fleet
Durham University’s exam concession towards students with disabilities – particularly those with dyslexia – have been seen by some as leading to such students being unfairly treated when their exams are marked, by not informing examiners of their disability in advance, and not informing disabled students of this policy.
The system of informing examiners about a student’s disability has been implemented by other universities such as Oxford and other Russell Group institutions, and applies to students’ work when it is both anonymous and non-anonymous.
In the case of dyslexia, this is said to help reduce the disadvantages dyslexic students face at university by allowing examiners to be put more focus on critical engagement and exam content rather than on a student’s spelling, punctuation and grammar (SPAG), something which dyslexic students struggle with due to their disability.
This system has not been implemented by Durham University. The Geography department’s online pages say that “A common question asked by students with dyslexia or a similar specific learning difficulty (SPld) is whether their work is marked differently or more leniently to allow for their disability while at University?
“At Durham University, the answer to this question is no. Any work submitted by students with dyslexia or similar condition is not marked any differently or any more leniently than those students without dyslexia.”
“Any work submitted by students with dyslexia or similar condition is not marked any differently or any more leniently than those without dyslexia”
durham university geography department
Palatinate spoke to a third year student who discussed her experiences with getting support for her dyslexia. Until her third year at Durham, the student – who asked to remain anonymous – believed that her work was marked with her disability in mind.
The University did not make her aware that examiners were not told about her disability. She did not become aware of this until feedback from an exam described her writing (which had SPAG errors due to her dyslexia) as “lazy”.
She was then referred by her academic advisor to the disability support service, who made her aware of the policy for the first time. She told Palatinate that “I didn’t realise that in order for my dyslexia to be taken into account in the marking that I had to fill out a SAC form otherwise the marker wouldn’t know.
“It was never made clear to me that that is what I should’ve been doing to make sure the marker knew my disability.”
When asked if her previous grades have been amended to account for her disability, she said that “I don’t think they have been amended yet (if they will be at all) as I’ve just filled out the SAC form for one module’s summative essay. Hopefully that one will be.”
She also argued that the University’s recommended strategies were ineffective in a high-stress environment such as a timed exam, and as such she is still left with a major disadvantage compared to non-disabled students.
“Exam concessions do not apply to any exams which have a 24-hour window or more, as they are deemed an inclusive method of assessment”
durham university
In response to these claims, Durham University said in a statement that: “We have a dedicated Disability Support Service – a friendly, approachable team of professionals who work with disabled students to discuss any academic difficulties encountered in relation to their disability throughout their time at Durham.
“Academic departments are made aware of each student’s individual disability via a Disability Support Plan once the student has engaged with the Disability Support service. This allows for in-year adjustments to be provided by academic departments and services, including access to a range of study skills across the University to help students to develop strategies to succeed in their academic studies
“We work with students to put a personal and tailored Disability Support Plan in place, which outlines agreed reasonable adjustments, including exam concessions. Much more information is available on our website and SharePoint site.”
On the website, Durham University also state that current exam concessions available to students include “additional time, use of a word processor (to type answers) or rest breaks”, and that “Exam concessions do not apply to any exams which have a 24-hour window or more, as they are deemed an inclusive method of assessment.”
Image: DS Pugh via Wikimedia Commons
