Rod Liddle’s return to the Durham Union
By Becks Fleet
Rod Liddle’s back. Remember him?
Yes, the newspaper columnist and infamous controversial guest at South College’s Christmas formal last year is scheduled to return to Durham in November, to speak at the Durham Union.
Liddle’s last visit to Durham didn’t go particularly smoothly; he was invited by South College Principal Tim Luckhurst to speak at South’s Christmas formal last year, and delivered a speech many considered full of transphobia (“a person with an X and a Y chromosome… is scientifically a man, and that is pretty much, scientifically, the end of the story”), defence of colonialism (“colonialism is not remotely the major cause of Africa’s problems”), and inappropriate comments on a ‘lack of sex workers’ in the room at night. Predictably, his speech angered many students at the formal – some of whom walked out mid-speech, only to be labelled “pathetic” by Luckhurst’s wife – and throughout the University, and led to major protests in the weeks and months that followed.
Another controversial figure to be invited to the Durham Union is Julie Bindel, who has had scheduled visits to the Union cancelled in the past. She’s best described as a TERF (Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist), in that she has progressive views regarding women’s rights and gender roles, but not for all women, apparently.
Inviting two notably transphobic speakers to the Durham Union is certainly a bold move, and one which is sure to be criticised heavily by much of the student body. However, I’d argue that the Durham Union is a much more suitable place for Liddle & Bindel than a college formal.
Inviting two notably transphobic speakers to the Durham Union is certainly a bold move
One of the major issues with Liddle’s presence at South’s Christmas formal was the nature of the event. My understanding is that Liddle’s appearance wasn’t well communicated by the College beforehand, meaning students attended (and paid for) the formal not expecting his speech, and formals just aren’t the sort of place where inviting controversial speakers makes sense. Formals are usually intended to be enjoyable, fun occasions where students can relax, drink wine and be with their friends. They are not intended to become debate chambers. Liddle’s presence at the formal – especially when many trans students were present and unaware of his speech beforehand – was massively inappropriate and went against many students’ expectations of what a formal should be.
However, his presence at a Durham Union event has been announced well in advance, meaning that those attending know exactly what to expect, and can choose not to attend if they don’t want to endure another night of bigotry. And at least this time, he won’t be left unchallenged; the event Liddle has been earmarked to attend is a debate about the University, where he’ll be opposed by student debaters and Conservative MP Richard Holden. Unlike at a Christmas formal, the Durham Union is full of students prepared and ready to challenge Liddle’s bigotry, in an environment where this is permitted and encouraged.
As a venue for such speakers, the Durham Union makes much more sense than a College formal
The same applies to Bindel. Although she’s not spoken at the University before, her views will likely be well known to attendees of her debate (about the rise of OnlyFans), and therefore she can be challenged on those views appropriately.
Although I don’t agree with many of Rod Liddle or Julie Bindel’s views, that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be invited to speak at the University whatsoever. However, the nature of their views means that many students would likely feel uncomfortable listening to their speeches, especially when their presence was unexpected. It’s hugely important that, if speakers such as Liddle and Bindel are invited, it’s in an environment where they are expected to speak and where they can be challenged and debated. As a venue for such speakers, the Durham Union makes much more sense than a College formal.
Illustration: Anna Kuptsova

