EU students less likely to repay loans, study finds

by Justin Villamil
graduation_large

The British government may be losing substantial amounts of money on loans made to EU students, a new study suggests.

Under current EU regulations, EU citizens are able to apply for the same government-backed loans as UK citizens.

However, The Telegraph has reported on recent research conducted by James Clappison, the Conservative MP for Hertsmere, which suggests 42-43% of EU students are not repaying their student loans. This figure can be compared with the 14% of total loans made by UK institutions which go unpaid.

This statistic could, however, indicate that 43% of EU students are not making enough money to clear the repayment threshold.

The Clappison report also revealed that EU students are ten times more likely to graduate and fail to report their location: as many as 22% of EU students did not notify the Student Loan Company (SLC) of their whereabouts after graduation. This compares to 2% of total student borrowers who can not be traced.

However, the Clappison report also found that EU students are more likely to pay their loans back early, with 18% of EU students paying before deadlines compared to just 4% of total loans.

This trend can be attributed to the UK repayment system (PAYE), which means repayments are tied to paychecks and are taken out automatically after students hit a salary over £21,000 per year.

In contrast, EU students are required to self-report their location and salary.  EU students are required to make their own payment scaled to their wages, a system which may well lend itself to abuse.

EU mainland students have accounted for £400 million in loans over the past six years, with over £100 million from 2010-2011.

The figures revealing low levels of repayment from EU students have provoked a measure of anti-immigration ire across the UK. A report in The Daily Mail noted that as tuition fees rise to around £9,000, this effect will multiply and may have serious repercussions for the UK.

Others, however, have simply called for a tightening of controls and oversight on these loans. James Clappison is among those calling for a change:

“I think this should raise serious questions with the Government about how effective we are at getting our money back through the student loans system. This is clearly an issue that needs a lot more attention particularly as tuition fees rise.”

Photograph: Wikimedia Commons