‘It is far safer to be feared than loved’ – Iran’s Modern Machiavelli

iranianflag300x200

by William Warr

Despite the hype around the forthcoming Iranian presidential elections, in which the Iranian people will elect a new president to replace the incumbent Ahmadinejad, it seems that more attention should be paid to the real caller of the shots in Iran; Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei.

Khamenei, 73, displays many of the characteristics of a Machiavellian prince. Here are three of them.

Firstly, Khamenei governs with an iron fist. 90 people have been executed in Iran already in 2013, the highest per capita execution rate in the world. Only seven of these had committed murder. The remaining 83 had committed non-murder related crimes, such as drug trafficking, robbery and rape.

Moreover, Khamenei is increasingly turning to public hangings, using modern cranes in order to instil fear into his population in an effort to cut rising crimes rates.

In The Prince, Machiavelli endorses the actions of an Italian duke, Cesare Borgia who has his weak subordinate, Messer Remirror cut ‘in two pieces in the public square with a block of wood and a bloody sword near him.’ Such a spectacle left the people ‘awestruck’.

Secondly, like Machiavelli, Khamenei also realises the limits of heavy handed rule, and has to combine it with other governing techniques in order to remain in power.

Religious manipulation is relentless in Iran. Khamenei knows how powerful governing through a ‘fear of God’ (Machiavelli) can be and therefore professes a relationship with The Hidden Imam, the 12th and last of Shia Imam’s who went into hiding in the year 941. Khamenei says that he is merely standing in for the Imam until he returns on the day of judgement.

Such a theocratic government allows Iran to portray itself ‘mere executor of the things ordained by God’ (Machiavelli) and thus not be as open to direct criticism itself, for Khamenei and his government are operating under ‘the cloak of religion’ (Machiavelli).

Finally, Iran’s nuclear programme shows all the traits of a Machiavellian project, driven by a combination of necessity to deter American and Israeli encroachment on its territory and through its ambition to become a global power. Machiavelli wrote ‘Whenever men cease fighting through necessity, they go to fighting through ambition’.

In 2002 George Bush declared that there were three countries that made up an ‘axis of evil’: Iran, Iraq and North Korea. He then proceeded to invade Iraq, which unsurprisingly spurred Iran and North Korea to acquire nuclear weapons in an attempt to deter the U.S. from invading them next.

Chief Nuclear Negotiator Ali Larijani, who appears to have The Prince as his bed side reading, said that ‘If Iran became atomic Iran, no longer will anyone dare challenge it, because they would have to pay too high a price.’

 Photograph: Tijl Vercaemer