Durham Students’ Union announces “preferendum” on strike position
By Emily Doughty
The Durham Student Union has announced that a “preferendum” will take place on Durham SU’s position on the upcoming strike action.
The “preferendum” will give students the opportunity to vote on what they think this position will be.
While the final positions for the “preferendum” are still under consultation, Durham SU has presented the initial four positions which are:
- I don’t support the UCU campaign at all and so I don’t support any campaign tactics.Â
- I can accept the disruption to my studies caused by strike action, but if I use my time to study I should get my work assessed, so I don’t support a marking boycott.
- I don’t accept any disruption to my studies, including strike action and any marking boycott, but I can accept that UCU members have the right to work to contract.
- I support the UCU campaign and will support in principle any campaign tactics UCU think will win their campaign.
“Setting a Student’s Union position on this should not be done just by elected reps, but by all students”
joe mcgarry, su president
On their website, Durham SU said that “The position of the Students’ Union matters because this is how Durham University understands the interests of students, and it will inform how we represent those interested across our work.
“Students have different, well-informed, and passionate views on this matter. We encourage everyone to vote for the position that best represents their beliefs, and to share their view and to campaign respectfully.”
Joe McGarry, the SU President, previously had said that “setting a Students’ Union position on this should not be done just by elected reps, but by all students.”
However, the referendum is not supported by all sabbatical officers with Josh Freestone, Officer for undergraduates, saying on social media that the statement “was rushed out without consultation, or the courtesy of a heads up” and that it “does not speak for me, I voted against this proposal at the Trustee board and will campaign to make sure workers on campus get the support they need”
He also said that he did not think that it was acceptable that the Trustee board, which he called “a largely unaccountable group”, could overturn the democratic mandate of student officers to support the UCU, which he believes he was elected on. He went on to call this “hugely offensive”.
The role of the Trustee Board in the decision was questioned by some students, with Ansh Bhatnagar calling it “a huge democratic overreach”.
The announcement has not been met with full support within the wider student community University and College Unions postgraduate group tweeting “Postgraduate researchers are currently still classed as students. We are valid members of the SU. And we will be going on strike.
“[The referendum] does not speak for me, I voted against this proposal at the Trustee board and will campaign to make sure workers on campus get the support they need”
Josh freestone, Undergraduate Officer
“It is ludicrous that there is a referendum on whether their own members should be supported or not. Would they ask ‘Should we support undergrads?'”
They went on to say that the decision goes against the mandate of two sabbatical officers who were elected supporting the UCU. They went on to question the legitimacy of the board “Was [the decision] taken by a majority of student-elected members? Or by the Board – which includes elected members?”
The Postgraduate UCU group also called the options “very leading and problematic. Their framing is a view that the causes UCU are fighting for have nothing to do with/diametrically opposed to that of taught students. Where’s the option for “I recognise staff and students are facing the same issues?”
“Despite the requests for ‘respectful debate’ this will cause nothing but division amongst the student body, and lead to PGRs feeling further isolated from an SU they feel doesn’t have their backs.”
“The Trustees haven’t made any decision on behalf of students, overturned any mandate or overreached anything”
durham su spokesperson
In a statement a Durham SU spokesperson said “Industrial action on campus impacts all students – undergraduate, postgraduate, taught and research – and there are clearly different views and competing interests on the matter. The Durham SU Board of Trustees, which is a majority of students directly elected by students including the Durham SU Officers, and a minority of external members appointed by elected students on Assembly, has therefore called a preferendum. It’s right that the entire student body resolve this question, democratically.
“We have heard the opinion that we shouldn’t consult students directly on one of the most important things to happen on campus this year, but we don’t agree. The trustees haven’t made any decision on behalf of students, overturned any mandate, or overreached anything; 89% of Durham students told us in independent research that they wanted to directly vote on all policy ideas and we respect our members, so that’s exactly what’s going to happen.
“Josh Freestone tweeted about the way in which the decision to call a preferendum was made, based on a misunderstanding about the process, and he has now deleted these tweets because they were not accurate. He remains of the view that the students’ union should support industrial action without the need for a vote, because there are many other priorities requiring Durham SU’s attention and, in any event, his successful manifesto strongly supported industrial action. We understand why Josh thinks that way, but we remain of the view that a vote of all students is the right thing to do on such an important matter.”
Campaigning for the “preferendum” will start on the 21st of November, with voting opening on the 28th of November. The vote will close on the 2nd December with results expected the same day.
Last week, The University and College Union (UCU) has announced that strike action will take place across all universities in the UK on Thursday 24th, Friday 25th and Wednesday 30th of November.
Image Credit: Amana Moore

