Dual citizenship: the new bureaucratic nightmare

By Herbie Langtry

For Britain’s 1.2 million dual citizens, people who have citizenship in both Britain (or Ireland) and another country, life will become more complicated on the 25th of this month,. From then onwards they will have to enter the country using only a British or Irish passport, rather than that of their other country. If these citizens want to enter the country using their foreign passport, they will need a Certificate of Entitlement, an unbelievably expensive £589 document verifying that they have the right to live and work in the UK. For dual citizens with a British or Irish passport, this is a minor inconvenience, but for those living abroad without one, it is incredibly disruptive. They will be denied entry to the UK unless they apply for a British passport (which often costs over £150), pay £589 for a Certificate of Entitlement, or pay £125 for an emergency travel document valid for just a single trip. 

With this policy the Government is essentially levying a tax on the specific people who have British citizenship but not a British passport. For that reason, the special class of British and Irish dual citizens will be able to enter regardless of which passport they use, giving them a strange kind of privilege over other dual citizens.

The Government is economically encouraging such people to renounce one of their citizenships, and punishing them for being loyal to more than one country

So why is the Government doing this? Officially, it’s a part of the new Electronic Travel Authorisation (ETA) regime being brought in by the Home Office. Travellers from countries that don’t require a visa to enter the UK now require an ETA. However, dual citizens cannot hold an ETA, since they already have right to live, work, and study in the UK indefinitely, so instead they must prove their citizenship before arriving.

Yet the high prices of the Certificate of Entitlement and emergency travel documents indicate that there is another motive for the new policy, namely income for the Government. For a Government looking to increase its revenue, simultaneously raising the costs of these certificates while increasing the number of people needing them can increase the Government’s funds without many voters noticing. If it is primarily about income, it explains why the policy feels designed to extract as much money from travellers as possible. Every person with birthright British citizenship who wants to travel to the UK now must pay either £150 every ten years for a British passport, £589 immediately, or £125 every time they come, a fairly large and consistent source of revenue to fund the Home Office. Even more deviously, these international families are a demographic that often can’t simply choose to travel somewhere else, since they are a lot more likely to be travelling to the UK to see friends and relatives rather than on holiday. 

Countries are becoming less of a symbol of pride and more of an irritating piece of bureaucracy

Yet if we view the policy as a tax, then it is a highly unfair one with concerning implications. Firstly, the fees are clearly disproportionate – everyone has to pay the same fees, rich or poor. Meanwhile, a tax that specifically targets multinational families feels bizarrely nationalist, as if they are against the idea of British and non-British people having children. It undermines the idea of birthright citizenship, that anyone with a parent who is a British citizen is themselves a British citizen at birth, if those who acquire British citizenship that way are subjected to fewer rights, higher fees, and more bureaucracy than people born and raised in Britain. Knowingly or not, the Government is economically encouraging such people to renounce one of their citizenships, and punishing them for being loyal to more than one country.

This whole fiasco reveals how strange the business of citizenship has become in the 21st century. As society has become wealthier and travel easier, more and more people may see their identity as a mixture of different cultures – their parents, their birthplace, where they grew up, where they would like to live. Especially among nations with peaceful relations, countries are becoming less of a symbol of pride and more of an irritating piece of bureaucracy. For governments, dual citizenship and internationally minded people can seem threatening – they imply that a country’s government is not necessarily the leader of a culture, but just the administrators of a chunk of land. But adding even more forms won’t change that – so long as people can enter and exit their country, internationalism will grow. The British Government needs to learn that people really can love them and someone else too.

Image: Jan Mies via APA-Images