Are The Chinese Communist Party and Kuomintang Reconciling?

By Avesta Afshari-Mehr

Last week, the People’s Republic of China’s Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and Taiwan’s Kuomintang (KMT) held their first cross-strait diplomatic talk since 2016. The two parties first severed ties amidst heightened tensions, as China diplomatically established that Taiwan’s supposed leadership are separatists, and that Taiwan is rightfully China’s 23rd province.

During the course of the forum, there were discussions on tourism; industrial development; energy; healthcare; and environmental protection; as well as an attempt to restore consistent forums in the future based on a shared acceptance of the “1992 Consensus,” which was a makeshift ‘understanding’ achieved by between the CCP and KMT in 1992 whereby there is a singular China (rather than two), but such a nation has “different interpretations” on what that constitutes. The current Taiwanese party in government, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), have never actually acknowledged this consensus, claiming that the CCP offer no consideration for the Republic of China to be interpreted as the real China, and argues that to accept such a consensus would be to suggest that Taiwan is a province of China.

”During the course of the forum, there were discussions on tourism; industrial development; energy; healthcare; and environmental protection”

Despite this, both sides vocally expressed desire to uphold such a consensus. China’s Taiwan Affairs Office Director, Song Tao (宋濤), argued that both sides are equally responsible for maintaining peaceful relations and protecting “their homeland” as well as the prosperity of citizens in both areas. However, he did argue against Taiwanese independence, and encouraged the residents of Taiwan to “stand on the right side of history.”

Despite the prevailing belief that Taiwan wishes to be wholly separate from China as a sovereign state entirely, KMT Vice Chair Hsiao Hsu-tsen (蕭旭岑) echoed the same policy, advocating against Taiwanese independence. Taiwan’s President Lai, however, appeared to criticise the KMT for holding such a forum and maintaining such a policy, whilst simultaneously trying to block a special defence budget seen as vital to defending against threats from China. Lai continued that Taiwan would only be on equal negotiating footing and exchanging when this special defence budget is approved.

Taiwan’s Mainland Affairs Council also criticised the forum, saying that “the MAC deeply regrets that, amid cross-strait tensions … the KMT still insists on adhering to the CCP’s so-called ‘1992 Consensus’” and argued that these KMT-CCP think tanks simply “cannot replace official cross-strait communication mechanisms,” and reminded the KMT that it is against the law to sign any political agreements with China without lead government authorisation.

”The KMT’s engagement with Beijing comes at a critical time, as China ramps up their military and naval exercises around Taiwan”

This reveals a substantial divide between the KMT and Taiwan’s leading party DPP, as the KMT insist that such a forum would bridge the gap between the two nations and improve prosperity for citizens of both jurisdictions; whilst the DPP argue that such a forum only strengthen’s China’s grip over Taiwan and works against Taiwanese interests.

There is no doubt that such forums fundamentally are intended to address and solve issues affecting both sides (such as tourism; AI; climate change; etc.), but both sides could well be using such a forum to further their understanding of the respective nation’s national security; supply chains; and wider critical infrastructure – to assist in the seemingly inevitable invasion of Taiwan.

The KMT’s engagement with Beijing comes at a critical time, as China ramps up their military and naval exercises around Taiwan, which brings about the question of whether the KMT are actually damaging Taiwan’s position against China by creating opportunities for CCP manipulation/coercing, or actually improving Chinese-Taiwanese relations.

Image: Shoshui via Wikimedia Commons