Don’t Go Bacon My Heart

By Adrian Chew
It’s been a tough time for all of us meat eaters. Late last month, the WHO’s cancer research working group, the IARC, gathered in Lyon and produced a report which proclaimed processed meats as “carcinogenic to humans” (Group 1) and red meat as “probably carcinogenic”.
The Group 1 classification now means that bacon (along with other less popular processed meats) sees itself on a list of far from savoury materials such as arsenic, asbestos, formaldehyde, UV radiation and tobacco.
Rather timely, it was released just days before the UK’s National Vegan Month, as social media erupted with the schadenfreude of vegans everywhere along with efforts to convert meat eaters to their cause. To be perfectly honest here, can you blame them? Imagine the reaction if a study had come out detailing that Quorn had links with some deadly disease or other. In fact, it was rather human in a way, that we all share an innate tendency to feel superior about our life choices.
But I digress; faced with such news, it is indeed tempting to take shot at the basis of the report on the collation of epidemiological studies (the study of health and disease in defined populations). The 2012 paper “Is everything we eat associated with cancer?” looked at 50 common cookbook ingredients and single-item medical articles on 40 of them that reported on their cancer risk. It was found that while 191 of 264 studies linked these common foodstuffs with cancer, over 75% of these studies had minimal statistical significance.
Alas, while there is some contention about this report within the academia (and indeed, even within the IARC itself), it is hard for me, as a layperson, to argue with a conclusion collated from over 800 studies, spanning decades on, issued by a panel of 22 international experts.
On the other hand, being put on that list is not the be-all-end-all. The IARC cites research that ties 34,000 cancer deaths annually across the world to processed meat-heavy diets, and studies that proclaim that eating an additional 1.8 ounces – the weight of 2 rashes of bacon – daily will lead to an 18% increase in the risk of contracting colorectal cancer. In comparison with another item on that list – tobacco, which has studies concluding that active consumption of cigarettes leads to a 1100% to 1300% increase in the risk of lung cancer – the figure for our humble rasher seems suitably modest indeed.
Perhaps what we’re all secretly hoping for is the off-chance that the medical community took its recommendations too far, and that we see a redemption story of bacon and red meat similar to that of saturated fats. Since the 1970s, the prevailing recommendation by medical authorities is that we avoid saturated fats in our diet due to its links with heart disease, given that it increases the amount of “bad cholesterol”, LDL, in our bloodstreams. However, recent studies and scholarly dissent have argued that this proved a gross caricature of the facts, with the most recent Annual Review of Nutrition positing that “blanket recommendations to the total saturated fats may not be appropriate”.
Sadly, applied to the case of processed meats, where nitrate-preserved meats are subject to the unpredictable process of being cooked under extreme heat, it seems highly unlikely. Of course, all of this presupposes that we are going to radically alter our diets because of this report – millions of meat lovers begrudgingly consigning themselves to a life of monastic veganism in the interests of leading a healthier life. I don’t see that happening any time soon, seeing how “bacon is good for me” is the fourth highest bacon-related search suggestion on Google.
In any case, there might be a case where we all win – meat-eaters, vegetarians, even pigs: researchers in Oregon have created and patented a species of seaweed, Dulse, which they claim to have “a pretty strong bacon flavour” when fried. Glorious. Best thing is, it has double the nutritional value of kale.
While it might take a while for it to enter commercial production, we might have good cause to drink our bacon-related sorrows away: according to a Reading University study published just this month, drinking three glasses of champagne a week can reduce the risk of developing dementia.
Photograph: Didriks via Flickr
