Do we have the right to revoke citizenship?

Shamima Begum and Hoda Muthana in the fight for citizenship.

 

FOR Revoking Citizenship

By Katie Fraser

Shamima Begum has recently been denied UK citizenship after leaving the UK to join Islamic State.

When she joined ISIS, she made a decision – a decision to abandon the country of her birth and join an organisation that actively seeks the downfall of Western society. When she left she made an active choice to align herself with a terrorist organisation and should be made to realise the reality of her decision.

Begum has said that she does not regret travelling to Syria but now fears for the future of her baby boy, whom she gave birth to in a Syrian refugee camp. Begum and her husband, Riedijik, fled the caliphate when it became clear that the state was destabilising, but Riedijik continues to be held in north-eastern Syria while Begum was left in a refugee camp.

She made an active choice to align herself with a terrorist organisation

Begum has said that: ‘I got tricked and I was hoping someone would have sympathy with me’ and yet she does not regret travelling to Syria and has, during her time in the Middle East, made clear her strong and violent anti-Western statements endorsing terror attacks against British society.

If she does not regret her journey to Syria, then how far is the government, and the British public, meant to believe that she no longer aligns herself with the ideologies of Islamic State? Affiliating herself with a militant organisation poses a very real security threat and allowing her UK citizenship would appear to gloss over this threat.

Begum’s father has positioned himself on the side of the government’s decision to revoke citizenship. Speaking to the Mail on Sunday he said: ‘I am on the side of the government […] If she at least admitted she made a mistake then I would feel sorry for her and other people would feel sorry for her. But she does not accept her wrong.’ Begum’s appeal for sympathy seems to be falling on deaf ears even from her family.

The British government’s decision demonstrates the establishment of a harder line policy towards those returning from the Islamic State.

 

AGAINST Revoking Citizenship

By Patrick Williamson

Hoda Muthana and Shamima Begum want to return to the United States and Britain respectively after leaving their countries to join Islamic State. Although both have affiliated themselves previously with strong anti-Western rhetoric, they are still entitled to their citizenship.

Begum, the daughter of a Bangladeshi, had her citizenship removed under the guise that she might be a citizen of Bangladesh, a country which denies this and which she has never visited. Muthana, daughter of a Yemeni diplomat, had her passport revoked in 2016. She was told her father’s position excluded her from US citizenship, despite him allegedly leaving his post before her birth.

Both women are now stateless.

Both Britain and the US committed themselves in 1954 to action against statelessness: Britain signed the UN Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Person, and the US Supreme Court declared citizenship deprivation as a punishment illegal. They recognised that citizenship is not just a matter of legal convenience, or a ‘licence which expires based on good behaviour’. It is the foundation of their system. Without citizenship, all other human rights guaranteed by states or the UN are unenforceable.

This is why this arbitrary removal by politicians playing to the gallery is so disconcerting. In particular, the ease at which the Home Secretary stripped Shamima Begum of her statehood, using Theresa May’s 2014 Immigration Act, is deeply troubling.

The legislation allows for the deprivation of statehood if the individual may be entitled to citizenship elsewhere.

But if Begum’s British citizenship can be removed because she might also be Bangladeshi, what value does it have and what becomes of others living in Britain with dual citizenship? How can dual citizens possibly feel as though their ‘Britishness’ is worth the same as anyone else’s?

Put them on trial, and let measures be taken if they have committed crimes.

Begum’s and Muthana’s experiences have been deeply traumatic. Begum was only fifteen when she was indoctrinated, groomed, and raped*, and Muthana left the United States when she was twenty, now attempting to return to the US with her eighteen-month-year-old child.

Shamima Begum and Hoda Muthana should be able to return. Put them on trial, and let measures be taken if they have committed crimes. Rehabilitation must not be shunned. Both women display varying degrees of regret and willingness to change.

But whatever action is taken it must be by Britain and the US. They are not Syria’s problem, or Bangladesh’s. They are citizens of Britain and the US, who must take responsibility.

*Note: Under the Sexual Offences Act 2003 it is considered an offence for a person over the age of eighteen to have sexual relations with someone under the age of sixteen. It is also illegal for a person in a position of trust to have sexual relations with anyone under the age of eighteen.

Photo: via Pixabay.