Discussions: Proving God?

Is it necessary to prove that there is or is not a God/Gods?

by Victoria Harris

Do I need to prove God exists to believe He exists? I don’t think so. We may never truly know whether there is a God or Gods, or not, but this does not stop millions and billions of people believing in a God, a force, a power or an ultimate being. As with many things, there are arguments either way; if this were a court, I doubt we as human beings would ever reach a unanimous verdict.

For me, religious or spiritual belief does not have to follow logic, reason or rationality. My faith is about love, grace, hope and forgiveness; and the abundance and mercy with which these are given does not follow the rules of logic, reason, or rationality. Faith is about feeling, gut instincts and connecting the head and the heart, the body and the soul, the thoughts and the actions. I believe in a God that is so far beyond my understanding that I often find it difficult to explain my relationship with Him; yet some part of me, deep down, knows He is always there. I cannot prove it, granted; nor do I particularly want or need to.

People who already believe do so without a totality of physical and rational proof, and solid evidence; they believe nonetheless. People who don’t believe in the existence of God also do so without the same level of proof; and continue to not believe nevertheless. To my mind, it seems gratuitous to spend time attempting to prove something in concrete and absolute terms; curiosity is a good thing, pointless conflict is most definitely not.

Belief and faith are rather subjective things; persuasiveness of arguments cannot change how someone truly feels ‘deep down’. In some ways, it may even be better not to know.  I’m not arguing we should stop looking for evidence, but faith and spirituality should be about making your own mind up, using whatever materials you have. It is often argued that humans are rational beings and therefore need some sense of logic. However, the longer I live, the more I see that suggests not only are humans not always logical and rational, neither is the world in which we live. How would we ever prove or disprove the existence of God? The comedian Al Murray has an interesting argument to ‘prove’ the existence of God, which you can watch HERE.

While I don’t entirely agree with him, he makes a good point. It’s not a point based on evidence, fact, proof or even just feelings and instincts. He makes the point that life is about living, and to continue living, you need to have a sense of humour. Proof will not help us convince others, justify our own personal belief or feelings, or influence the world around us. We do that through being, not arguing or proving a point. We are all different people and that is why we believe in different things.

by Sam Barker

Is it necessary you prove the existence of god/s to explain the weather? Clearly not, we have many other possible explanations. Is it necessary to prove the existence of god/s if you want to to convince Richard Dawkins of their existence? Almost certainly.

There are many interesting treatments of the question – is it necessary for us to prove the existence of god/s in order to justify a belief in them? I am broadly sympathetic to this idea and  I do not think that on a personal level, it is necessary to prove the existence of god/s to justify a belief, or to dodge an accusation of delusion or wrong-mindedness.

On the other hand, if we want to use the belief in god in a public setting, to justify further claims it becomes far more complicated.

I may claim a profound connection of a being beyond my comprehension revealed to me by revelation, by the world, by some kind of intuition.  I may use the existence of this being to justify the truth of a set of holy books, and the content therein. I may choose to live my life by the rules laid down in a text of this kind. I may ask the state and those around me to allow me to live in this way – which they cannot fully understand – to facilitate my doing so by removing obstacles and preventing my being discriminated against for living my life this way.  All of this seems fine to me without proof of the existence of said god/s.

Problems arise however when my actions, my way of life, my behaviour (based as it is fundamentally on the existence of god/s) start impacting in any serious way upon other people, forcing them to live their lives a particular ways, restricting them, harming them. Similar problems arise if I want to justify why my way of life is the best way to someone else, to convince governments to pass laws forcing others to live as I do.

If I aim to convince others by use of rational argument of the existence of god/s, or of any facts I see as entailed by it, then I am going to run into problems. Whilst all arguments are going to have some kind of challengeable foundations at their basis, at the bottom of my chain of reasoning lies a foundation that is not only unproven or uncertain, but highly contentious – it seems to many impossible or even proven not to be the case. We therefore cannot use it as the basis of a rational argument of this kind.

My contention then is that if the existence of god/s is going to be used as a premise in any kind of argument about public policy – marriage laws, abortion laws, faith schooling of children – then some kind of proof is going to be required.

 

If you would like to write for Discussions debating theological and philosophical issues then please email blogs@palatinate.org.uk!

Photograph: NASA