Debate: Is a no-deal Brexit the best option? AGAINST
Charlie Hetherington
It certainly has romance. Instead of untangling forty years of bothersome legislation, why not have a clean break? A brave, buccaneering Britain unshackled from the continent, sailing out and into the wider world! Sadly, the reality is not quite as swashbuckle – a ‘No Deal’ Brexit would be an unmitigated disaster for the UK.
As a messy breakup would poison any good-will, Britain would likely become the only major economy trading with the rest of the world solely on WTO terms
On the 29th of March, Britain automatically leaves the EU under Article 50. If no agreement is reached and approved legislatively, we crash out in a ‘No Deal’ Brexit, threatening to break every promise made so far in the withdrawal agreements, including on citizens’ rights, a £40 billion ‘divorce bill’ and the Irish border. To some this seems ideal, Some Brexiteers crave for this, calling for trade on WTO terms and the chance to ditch EU rules. These are harmful delusions.
Take the economy. Keeping any EU trade deals with countries like Canada or Japan requires Brussel’s permission and, as a messy breakup would poison any good-will, Britain would likely become the only major economy trading with the rest of the world solely on WTO terms (The next largest belongs to Mauritania, a country with a GDP 0.3% the size of Britain’s).
Severe effects on inflation and the public finances, the North East would be hammered with a 16% blow
Customs too would be swamped. With no deal, Britain would be ejected from the EU’s regulatory zone and any exports subject to a myriad of checks. Presently, it takes two minutes when heading for Europe to pass through customs but twenty minutes for a non-EU destination. As around 7000 trucks pass through Dover alone each day, enormous delays would result with costs passed on to consumers. Manufacturers who rely on ‘Just-In-Time’ shipments would run out of parts: Toyota, Aston Martin and Honda have all warned they would have to stop production.
The Treasury believes such an outcome would mean a massive loss of 7.7% of GDP relative to the status quo, with equally severe effects on inflation and the public finances. Moreover, this aggregate figure masks harsher regional impacts: the North East would be hammered with a 16% blow.
Britain would also fall out of all EU agreements providing the legal basis for things like the transfer of radioactive cancer treatments and the import of medicines. New regulatory bodies take years to set up and, in the meantime, Britain is far from self-sufficient: the domestic supply of insulin produces less than 0.5% of demand, for instance. To avert this, ‘micro-deals’ for individual issues have been suggested. Each of these would require the assent of every EU Parliament, yet this is unlikely in an atmosphere of acrimony.
This is the true horror of a ‘No Deal’ Brexit. Britain would tear itself out of international structures, putting it at other countries’ mercy. Will France build enough customs infrastructure? Will Russia allow our ascension to the WTO?
A chaotic exit would be a gross failure of government and an international humiliation. The UK will hardly be swaggering on the high seas, but rather ferrying across ‘adequate’ food.
Photo Credits: Muffinn via Flickr
