DEBATE: Extinction Rebellion ban.
The climate change protest group, Extinction Rebellion, have been banned from carrying out protests in London. This decision was made after days of protests throughout the centre of the English capital. Josh Preston and Kai Dattani debate whether the ban will be effective in curtailing a movement that has become out of hand or whether it will lay the groundwork for more volatile protests, respectively.
Josh Preston
After Extinction Rebellion’s antics over the weekend, I sincerely hope their hysteria is correct and we all die. I can never unsee that horrific inbetweeners – style hippy ‘dancing’ on Trafalgar square and so the only remedy is a swift end in cataclysmic fashion.
There is a fine line between protest and public nuisance
Unfortunately their doom mongering, like their dress sense, is emphatically wrong and so the next best thing was to ban the sorry event. And yet, the rather worn Voltairean adage that ‘I wholly disapprove of what you say— and will defend to the death your right to say it’ does apply.
To a degree. There’s a fine line between protest and public nuisance, a line mediated by the people who finally found that the lady doth protest too much. Only 30% of pollers agreed with the Extinction Rebellion protest, whereas 53% were outwardly opposed to it.
The tube fracas during morning rush hour was the epitome of arrogance
The police action was legal, and the notion of brutality a falsehood. Consider Catalonia, Hong Kong, or Venezuela for comparison. Our police are purposeful; they wear hi-vis and carrying protestors deftly into police vans like a restless child to a pram, which is how they behave. One smothered himself in Marmite like an unsupervised three year-old.
Yet their petulance displays itself most obviously in their total dis- regard for normal, working Londoners. They cost £37m in police provisions, straining resources during London’s knife-crime epidemic. The Tube fracas at east London Tube stations during morning rush hour was the epitome of arrogance, and commuters reacted predictably with anger.
Extinction Rebellion care nothing for consequences, using unfounded catastrophic language to justify their insane demands under which which flying would end, 38 million cars would be scrapped and 26 million gas boilers disconnected for a start. They would plunge people into abject poverty and cause millions of deaths worldwide, when no evidence or reputable organisation shares their views. The children have had their fun, returning the capital to normal was long overdue.
Kai Dattani
It is fair to say that Extinction Rebellion’s reputation has soured a fair amount recently. What originated over summer as a much needed, young, progressive movement tackling the big banks and corporations of London has seen its stock fall dramatically, as protestors targeted commuters not from Nationwide, but from working-class Newham, with this particular incident descending into chaos condemned by both the left and the right.
For the police, this was the last straw, and now, XR find themselves faced with a Section 14: a comprehensive ban on their demonstrations across London.
Protest, by its very nature, must have the ability to disrupt
However, what seems like a victory for law and order in the short term may cause even more chaos in the long run. As XR is gradually swept out of London by a zealous and interventionist police force,
it is not the aggressive, disruptive train climbers who are facing the wrath, but instead the rather peaceful, campers who have set up tents across the streets of London. Protest, by its very nature, must have the ability to disrupt, and those who have camped and organised peaceful demonstration against the climate emergency have managed to do this whilst still capturing the hearts of many environmentally concerned Londoners.
The climate emergency isn’t going away and neither is Extinction Rebellion
This overly interventionist ban comes in the context of a gen- eral hardening of Britain’s police force – exemplified by Priti Patel’s speech earlier this month. It therefore, has the potential to drive away the more moderate protestors, and lay the foundations for a ‘police versus the people’ narrative inspiring the future of XR. This paves the way for future protest to look less like Smiths-listening, banner-waving teenagers on Westminster Bridge, and more like something similar to London’s 2011 riots. Today’s climate emergency is not going away any time soon, and therefore by extension, neither is Extinction Rebellion. Harder policing and banning of demonstration will only push the movement in a hardened, anti- establishment direction, fighting not against climate change, but against its own oppression.
Photograph: Callum Shaw on Unsplash
