De-growth: the environmental solution you probably haven’t heard of

By Richard Waters

Let’s start with what seems a simple question: why has nothing changed? When we’ve been told there’s a renewable energy revolution, recycling is at an all-time high, and we are more aware than ever, why do atmospheric CO2 concentrations continue to rise, followed by global temperatures?

The answer is simple, but the solution is difficult. It is difficult because it forces you, me, and – crucially – those in charge, to change what has been championed for the last 6 or 7 generations. This issue is compounded by the fact that economic growth, the traditional yardstick of a government’s performance, is intrinsically linked to the destruction of the environment.

The answer is simple, but the solution is difficult

Certainly, minor changes have been proposed, but they are subject to the same assumptions and paradigms responsible for the creation of this crisis. Well-meaning tweaks and tinkering have not worked and never will. The solution must be radical.

The solution must be radical

There could be one solution, which is hardly ever given airtime yet could well be the answer to an increasingly urgent challenge. I’m going to be talking about GDP growth.

Every day we consume more. Each time the sun rises more fuel is burnt. By the time it sets, more money is made. Running alongside this is an increasingly inescapable set of effects. Growth means consumption and efforts to disentangle the two have been ineffectual.

The very environment that provides the resources for our growth and consumption necessarily must absorb the resultant effects

Acute symptoms are, for the moment, expressed largely in spaces far away from those who consume most, embodied by the sea-level threat towards isolated communities in the Western Pacific and the Arctic Circle. But increasingly, as the ever more frequent droughts and wildfires in Australia have shown, these effects will be at the doorstep of those countries who consume the most.

All of this is underpinned by a very simple reality that so often escapes our thinking. The very environment that provides the resources for our growth and consumption necessarily must absorb the resultant effects.

A better kind of consumption may help, but it is not the answer. Environmental complacency must be replaced by environmental realism. We have to understand that if we do not question the fundamental assumption of our economy, the idea that our cake can keep on getting bigger, every species on this planet will face a catastrophe. It simply cannot be over-stressed.

We have a choice. Growth will end one way or another. It can end through environmental catastrophe, with uncontrolled contraction as we confront the natural limitations of our planet. Disaster would pile upon disaster. Millions more would be plunged into poverty.

Environmental complacency must be replaced by environmental realism

But we do not have to reach this level. The other option is curbing this growth before this point is reached. Rather than relying on blind faith in innovation, we can act to check the appetite for more growth.

Immediately, GDP must cease to be the normal standard of assessment for policies. A new metric should be introduced, one that incorporates the happiness of a population and the environmental costs of its actions.

Equally, options that break the link between achievement and consumption such as a Universal Basic Income and a 4-day working week need to be brought into the mainstream of the political agenda. These are not without social benefits either. There is an equally compelling case for de-growth on a social level.

It will take a brave national leader to tell us that our cake cannot forever get bigger

It will take a brave national leader to tell us that our cake cannot forever get bigger. That kind of talk doesn’t, at the moment, win votes. But we need to put norms and preconceptions aside and recognise our complacency in the face of environmental disaster that is coming, slowly but unremittingly, ever closer.

Image by Ian Burt, via Flickr.