A study in crime: The Closed Casket

By Milly Munro

For anyone who is a lover of crime fiction classics, Sophie Hannah is definitely a name to remember. Hannah has a range of works, but some of her finest centre around one of the most famous characters in crime – Hercule Poirot. Agatha Christie’s beloved Belgian returns for some more mystery solving, reincarnated by Hannah. Taking on one of the most well-known characters in crime is no easy task but fear not – this is a wonderful crime novel to sink your teeth into.

The Closed Casket has an intriguing premise – Poirot and Catchpool are amongst a group of guests invited to a seemingly innocent weekend in the country by a famous author, Lady Playford. At dinner, Lady Playford makes a bewildering announcement. She has decided to write her children out of her will and leave everything to her terminally ill secretary. This unravels a series of events which show the invitations of Catchpool and Poirot may not have been as innocent as they seemed.

Sophie Hannah is definitely a name to remember

The Closed Casket is not Hannah’s first reincarnation of Poirot. The novel follows another Poirot novel by Hannah called The Monogram Murders, another fantastic read. In both novels, Hannah sprinkles little hints here and there to keep the reader hooked until the very end. The suspect list in The Closed Casket seems endless, with the unpleasantness between the Playford family getting deeper and deeper as more is revealed.

The plots feel very Agatha Christie-esque, but Hannah manages to avoid creating just a bad copy of the well-loved characters. She undermines even the most basic assumptions the reader makes about characters in the novel and even has another Poirot book out which follows The Closed Casket. These books don’t need to be read in order or even together; they can be read as stand alone novels.

The suspect list in The Closed Casket seems endless

For any lovers of classic Poirot, don’t be put off by the modernity of this writer – she doesn’t disappoint. This is a good read for anyone looking for a familiar face in crime but with a lighter edge to it. These Poirot mysteries are still set in the twentieth century; Hannah manages to recreate the world of Poirot despite being a modern writer. Even little things about Poirot that make him so well loved are captured by Hannah – down to his accent and his catchphrases (the little grey cells crop up every now and then). Whilst the true magic of Agatha Christie is hard to imitate, Hannah does a pretty solid job and the result is a thrilling, twisting Poirot mystery.

Image by JoĂŁo Silas via Flickr Creative Commons