Critics of Israel – Anti-Semites by Proxy?
By Mason Boycott-Owen
Labour MP Chris Bryant has recently cautioned the Labour Party from allowing anti-Semitism within its ranks because of their sympathies towards the Palestinian people. Writing in The Times he called over-zealous attacks on Israel as “anti-Semitism by proxy.”
Anti-Semitism is a word many people, most of all the Jewish communities around the world and at Durham University, wish they would never have to hear again.
Many critiques of Israel’s policies, just as with Chris Bryant’s words, are well meaning. They are prompted not by a hatred for the Jewish peoples but because of the humanitarian care for those who have died, on both sides, of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
We cannot conflate a critical eye of a state who has and is willing to commit crimes against human life with a word so emotionally charged with such hurt and turmoil for Jewish peoples. This breaks down debate and colours well-meaning arguments with a darker side that for many is not there in the slightest.
And yet, there is much about Israel which must be criticised from a humanitarian standpoint. Since the turn of the millennium there have been around over 10,000 deaths resulting from the conflict. Over 9,000 of these are Palestinian deaths (Source: B’Tselem, The Israeli Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories). Around 2,000 of those are children (Source: Remember These Children).
Chris Bryant says people on the left of British politics have allowed ‘concern for the Palestinians’ to become an all-out attack on the Israelis. For many, it has. Few can forget the shocking comments of George Galloway, who himself was once a member of the Labour Party, that Bradford, my home-city, is an “Israel-free zone.” These type of comments only lower the tone of debate and worsen already strained ties between the two peoples.
And yet Israel’s spokespeople have not given the international community much cause for hope of changing attitudes. Chief Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef recently said in a sermon “If our hands were firm, if we had the power to rule, then non-Jews must not live in Israel.” The fact that it is preached that only Jews can live in Israel understandably gives the international community pause for thought. This is only exacerbated when the most recent religious proclamation of religious exclusion came from ISIS banning all Christians from Raqqa. Obviously I do not equate the two but only highlight how religious exclusion is understandably criticised, in its violent and non-violent forms.
“There needs to be a balanced discussion. With so many disputes and problems around the world, the disproportionate attention and blame given to Israel is overwhelming. I think it being the world’s only Jewish state is no small factor” Alex Tansey – Former President of Durham University Jewish Society
Yet so much scrutiny is afforded to Israel in the dispute that often the transgressions of Palestine are left unmentioned. Rocket attacks and other killings are committed by Palestinians and the political party which claims to represent them are equally as culpable as the actions of Israel. Hezbollah is still considered, albeit by the United States, as a terrorist organisation – yet this is seen by some as part of the ongoing lack of legitimisation of Palestine in the international community.
Beyond Palestine, Israel do have legitimate worries. Nations such as Iran have made it de facto foreign policy to destroy Israel – and as such, the fears of the Israeli people about the increasing nuclear capability of nations which wish them harm are not irrational. “I’d say (to Israel) that they will not see (the end) of these 25 years” – Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.
As well as looking to the present we must also look to the past. Every critique of Israel has always has the undercurrent of the elephant in the room of the vile torment Jewish peoples have been through in the 20th century, and rightly so, such a heinous chapter of human history cannot be forgotten lest it happen again. As such anti-Semitism cannot be invoked so liberally, as it arguably has been by Chris Hughes, when many criticisms do not come close.
The scrutiny which has been afforded to Israel has been given to other religious states such as Iran and the dangers of theocracy and Zionism have to be noted, when its results can be seen in the bodies of Israeli and Palestinian alike lying over the West Bank and Gaza. It is only natural that the sight of such waste of human life is questioned by many in the UK and beyond. Yet this scrutiny must have the same respect and eloquence which is afforded to any other nation.
The western world should treasure its freedom to criticise religion and religious regimes on a humanitarian basis, as this concern to preserve life is what could one day bring about peace in the region. This freedom to criticise is also a freedom that many do not have, and something the western world does not remember enough.
‘‘Criticism of Israel is not by default anti-Semitic. But militant anti-Zionism and hateful comments about Israel often mask or lead to anti-Semitism, hence why anti-Semitism statistically always rises when there is an Israeli-Palestinian conflict.” Simon Zeffertt, President of Durham University Jewish Society
Photograph by Daniel Edwins via Flickr
