Air Strikes: We’re only helping, not hindering terrorism

By Victoria Lincoln

The American-led opinion in the West is that if you bomb everything in the Middle East it will be okay, but case studies from Pakistan, Afghanistan and the Iraq War foreshadow the failure of air strikes in Syria and Iraq. We are kidding ourselves if we think the millions of pounds we’re dropping in bombs on the Levant is going to stem the rise of ISIS and other radical Islamist groups, and replace them with stable democratic states. I am not soft on terrorism, nor am I a pacifist, but the track record of air strikes makes it a poor approach for long term stability. You cannot bomb an ideology out of people.

The US-led coalition is a mixture of 15 states including Australia, Bahrain, Netherlands, Denmark, France, Jordan, Morocco, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom and Canada as well as some rebel and local groups on the ground. This collection of forces against ISIS has many convergent ideas and interests. They have no coherent agreement on who should lead Syria in the future nor how they can end the civil war. Even if the air strikes push back ISIS, as they have in some regions, what follows is not stability, but rather a dangerous power vacuum. This power vacuum is a breeding ground for new Islamic groups like Al-Nursa. It is a self-perpetuating circle of air strikes, new terrorist groups and instability.

Key targets of air strikes in Syria have been focused in Aleppo, Raqqa, Hasakan and Kobani. In Iraq targets have focused on Ramadi, Mosul and the areas to the south and west of the city and Al Baghdadi. The official civilian death toll is 16. This is contested, but as human collateral goes this is successful compare to similar strikes in Afghanistan and Pakistan. However, the infrastructure and industry in Syria has been levelled. The long term implications of these strategic strikes are obviously negative. It’s already hard enough to try and build a stable state in the Middle East as we are seeing in Tunisia, Libya and Iraq, without trying to build it from complete rubble. At least we got the oil producing cities back in the area! Strikes have pushed back ISIS in some areas, the most recent being Palmyra, but overall the amount of land recovered from them since 2014 seems negligible. Air strikes are not the best way to target the guerrilla tactics of ISIS.

Russian air strikes have thrown a wild card in the mix. Their support of Assad is a burden on the US coalition’s political aspirations no matter how weak they are to create a democratic government. Russian air strikes have strengthened Assad, but has increased the amount of land ISIS controls as they take advantage of the power vacuum left by defeated rebel groups. It’s a high-stakes game and the fact that the US and Russia struggle to coordinate policy undermines any potential success of air strikes.

All the bombing in the world is not going to help Syria or Iraq. 45 % of the Syria population is displaced and 11.5% of the population is dead or injured. This is not the climate where more violence is going to bring stability only more anti-western sentiment and further Islamic groups – the real issue if ISIS is an ideology. You cannot kill an idea with weapons. The real battle should be against poverty, lack of education, deprived women’s rights and economic opportunity in the region. Many Muslims are turning to ISIS because they do not see a better alternative. We need to provide a better alternative. Maybe it is time for a carrot not a stick.

Photography by Matthew Allen Hecht via Flickr