Constant negativity in news: deliberate strategy or the reality?

By Amy Whitaker

Mainstream news companies have faced their fair share of criticism in recent years when it comes to the content they produce. From doom-scrolling on social media to tuning in to BBC News at Ten, it feels like we are inundated with an endless cycle of war, violence, human rights violations, natural disasters, and all kinds of other forms of suffering. These issues are unfortunate yet inevitable parts of our reality, but it seems suspiciously unbalanced to maintain such a predominant focus on depressing news stories. Is this a deliberate strategy by the media? Or is the overwhelmingly negative news stream merely a reflection of the world we are living in?

It is no secret that bad news sells: the huge numbers of views generated by negative news headlines suggest these are the kinds of stories people want to read, and the media is ultimately driven by demand. Positive news simply doesn’t evoke the same emotional response in readers as negative news does, fuelling an anxiety, fear, or anger that compels people to stay tuned in and share these stories on social media. It’s a perverse kind of fascination, like a car crash we can’t look away from. In fact, a study by Pew Research Centre found that when asked to choose between news that is informative or entertaining, the majority of people choose the latter. For news companies, then, it’s simple: depressing news equals more revenue. 

It is no secret that bad news sells

However, it might be unfair to suggest that news media outlets are solely motivated by profit. Above all, as the watchdogs of society, journalists do have a primary responsibility to find truth and keep the public informed on what is happening in the world, regardless of how unpleasant these reports may be. It is fundamental that a spotlight is cast on oppression and injustice that would otherwise remain hidden from view – although there are sadly still many forms of suffering that are forced to fight for important space in mainstream news – and that journalism continues on its mission to hold accountable those in power. 

With that being said, there is definitely a growing sense that being faced with such an over-abundance of negative news on a regular basis can have very real consequences for our mental health. Some psychologists have argued that a constant exposure to bad news can lead to depression, anxiety, and even post-traumatic stress disorder in the very worst cases. Feelings of helplessness and stress are heightened, as we so often close our news apps riddled with a nihilistic sense that so much in the world is out of our control. It’s always an odd feeling, hopping along the tabs on my laptop screen from an article about day 404 of the Ukrainian invasion or the droughts ravaging California, back to JSTOR to continue researching my summative like the world isn’t falling apart outside my window. 

What would happen if we had a more balanced news diet?

So, what would happen if we had a more balanced news diet?

While serious issues cannot and should not be ignored, prioritising positive stories of progress, resilience and human connection could help foster a more nuanced and hopeful view of the world among readers and inspire people to become more active in making a difference if they realise the value of doing so. 

One example of a news outlet attempting to counteract the negativity bias that currently exists in the media is the website Shareably. Their mission is to “create and curate uplifting, inspiring stories that reflect the best of humanity”, instead of focusing on the usual sensational headlines. They highlight acts of kindness, animal rescues, and positive social movements. While they are not a traditional news organisation, their approach is incredibly refreshing and speaks to the hunger for more positive news, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

Another example is the organisation Positive News. Founded in 1993, they aim to “report on progress, possibility and solutions, not just doom and gloom”, covering topics from environmental sustainability to social justice to technology. Both Shareably and Positive News offer a reconfigured perspective on what news can be, reminding us there is still good in the world and making it just as visible as all the not so good stuff. 

Image credit: Jamie I via Flickr