Come Dine With Me: second helpings

By Charlotte Allen

Photography by Alice Gwynne

For all of the comments, the marks that were given, all the inappropriate comments and a fuller look into the evening, watch the video here on Palatinate TV. For all recipes visit Palatinate Food & Drink online.

The second host: Greg Carter, PhD in Psychology, President of Castle Middle Common Room

The Menu:

Caramelised onion and goat’s cheese tartlet

Slow-roasted pheasant, wrapped in bacon, with pork stuffing with garlic and rosemary roast potatoes, brussel sprouts sautéed in butter and almonds, and sweet potato mash with double cream and nutmeg

Homemade Bramley apple crumble with real vanilla custard

Once the Palatinate crew eventually get into Greg’s building (after circulating the building, cajoling our way in the back door from a stranger and then discovering that we’d actually parked directly beside the front door), we find him in a bit of a state.

Due to an overrun meeting, Greg is a good 40 minutes behind. He won’t let me see his happily roasting pheasant, nestling beneath its wreath of foil, and he is busily instructing a minion (or housemate) on what to get for vegetarian Alison. He is also setting about his (shamefully ready-made) puff pastry for the tartlets, whilst trying to be at his most welcoming.

When questioned about his pastry Greg assures me he has stuffed his own pheasants, made his own crumble and prepared all other components entirely single handedly. As he flurries over his potatoes, his minion arrives with a butternut squash, along with the other guests. He brandishes the squash, and in the mileu of the guests arriving, asks me how to cook it. After assuring him that he probably shouldn’t just roast it whole, he hurries off to finish his preparations.

With Greg busy, Francesca, Alison and I discuss yesterday’s visit to Castle Formal. I won’t go too into this, as it will be covered in Indigo’s feature on formals. I can say nevertheless, that it involved gowns (always something exciting for us gown novices), many beautiful panelled rooms and a bit too much red wine.

After a small pause, during most of which Greg buries himself in the kitchen, the starter is served.  As usual, the good company makes time fly, so I am happy to ignore my growling belly. Admittedly, the goat’s cheese tartlet is dwarfed by the massive plate it is served on, but it is completely delicious. It is probably becoming obvious by now that I am very easily wooed by food; but this slice of crumbly, warm goat’s cheese melts on the tongue without being too, well, goaty. Mature cheeses can have a musty after-taste, but this one is smooth and rich, not to mention lovely to look at on the plate. The caramelized onions add a rough sweetness, and all too quickly I have snarfled the lot.

Conversation whisks happily on, but there is a gap before the pheasant is served. Greg hides his flusteredness well, presenting his veg for us to help ourselves to. I hate to admit it, but I have never tried pheasant, so I am particularly looking forward to this course.

It certainly does not disappoint.

The meat is rich, moist, and bursting with flavour. Despite concerns about two types of potato side, the accompanying dishes complement the meat well, both in taste and in colour. Even the squash meets with Alison’s approval. I eye Greg knowingly at this point, but he doesn’t own up, and I keep my mouth shut.

Conversation flows as easily as before, and we stray from topic to topic without problem. Greg however, is often absent from the table, but I can forgive him this, as in the kitchen I am not known for my speed.

Greg’s crumble puts a new angle on one of my solid comfort foods. I am used to thick, biscuit toppings but this one is nut based, a combination of roughly chopped walnuts, hazelnuts and pecans. Although sadly something amongst the dessert has the slightly acrid taste of being burnt (although I cannot ascertain whether this is the result of overheated custard or slightly over crisped nuts; possibly Greg’s heavy handed wine pouring is having an effect again?) the overall effect is homely and warming. I don’t hesitate to dig in for more.

When we are given an opportunity to snoop around Greg’s room, we find it up a small winding staircase. Each one of us stops in the doorway in awe, gazing at the spacious room, complete with partner’s desk, lounge chairs and the original wooden beams in the roof. On closer inspection, Greg’s room boasts a hearty collection of ties, many pheasant related (to match his outstanding trousers, covered with little pheasants) and a staggering amount of tweed. I can’t help being drawn to the broad desk; as Alison puts it, something like that would encourage you to do your work. We are happily snooping, when Greg calls up to us, telling us to open the curtains. Bemused, I lean across and pull the chord.

Staring beadily at me is a large stuffed pheasant.

Yes, you read correctly. Greg keeps a real stuffed pheasant, better known as Francis, on a shelf directly above his bed. I can’t help wondering if he has ever toppled from that position, and what a horrible surprise finding him in one’s bed would be. The beady eyes follow me wherever I go around the room, as though they can tell the things I am thinking about him.

Greg’s after dinner entertainment involves “Articulate”, a game all students should be familiar with. He also brings out his big surprise – his very own shisha.

Let me say right now that I am a bit nervous of anything involving smoke; maybe I’m over cautious, maybe I’m a wimp, but to me it seems unnatural to be taking anything other than oxygen into one’’s windpipes. I peer curiously on as he sets it up, telling us that he has chosen the apple flavour.

Of course, I am the one who starts spluttering and gasping indelicately at the first whiff. It leaves a soft, cinnamon aftertaste, and feels… well, odd. Greg tells us he uses this and his pipe to relax. I really can see Greg leaning back in his easy chair, pipe in hand, in a Sherlock-esque fug of smoke, complete in pheasant regalia…

This pleasant entertainment brings a thoroughly pleasant (should I say pheasant?) evening to an end. As his guests leave, they compliment Greg on his hosting skills, although they did notice his absence during dinner. Despite some small qualms, such as my  wineglass being dirty and mismatched cutlery and plates,  I really can’t fault him. I was very surprised by the pheasant (both in the bedroom, and in the kitchen), and as usual Greg was an accommodating, polite and affable host. As we leave, warm with food and of course wine, I quake slightly at how I will fare at my dinner party, less than a week from now.