Code red for American democracy?
By Alex Jennings
There are many timeless issues in American politics: unending debates across the political divide over matters which stretch back decades. Voting rights is a case in point.
This centrepiece of democracy has seen renewed focus since the 2020 Presidential election, as at least 18 Republican-controlled states have sought to pass laws curtailing when, where, and how their citizens can vote, as well as giving legislators greater control over the certification of federal elections, which, in effect, enables politicians to control results.
Advocates of these measures claim that they will guard against voter fraud, which many Republicans now believe was a widespread issue in 2020, following Donald Trump’s continuing yet baseless declarations that he won in a “landslide”. Democrats, however, have framed such laws as the greatest threat to American democracy since the Civil War. In July, Joe Biden pulled no punches in asserting the changes as “an attempt to suppress and subvert the right to vote and fair and free elections”, while congressional Democrats have been trying for months to bring in new federal voting rights legislation to reinforce national standards for voting.
At least 18 Republican-controlled states have sought to pass laws curtailing when, where, and how their citizens can vote
“Failure is not an option,” declared Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer earlier this year. But the reality is that failure now seems the most likely outcome. Sweeping reform of voting law through the “For the People Act” was blocked by Republican senators in June. Then a new, slimmed-down bill, called the “Freedom to Vote Act,” also failed to pass the Senate in October. Hope of ratifying legislation now lies with the chance of either Krysten Sinema or Joe Manchin, two Democratic Senators, agreeing to modify the Senate rules, thereby allowing the new law to pass with a simple majority. Neither has indicated any support for such an alteration, though.
The vanishing prospect of standardising federal election rules before next year’s congressional mid-term elections has therefore set alarm bells ringing. Losing control of either the House of Representatives or the Senate in 2022 would put a complete stop to the Democrats’ legislative agenda. And with Trump reportedly plotting a return to the White House in 2024, there are fears that his talk of voter fraud in 2020 has given way to a nationwide campaign by his supporters to deliver him the presidency by whatever means necessary. Indeed, the handful of Republican state officials who upheld the democratic process and refused to declare fraud or “find” more votes for Trump in 2020 are being substituted for more loyal players.
But the true issue at hand seems to extend deeper: a problem of disintegration and the breakdown of national cohesion
Accepting unfavourable election results and the temporary rule of those with whom we disagree is surely a fundamental requirement of liberal democracy. However, it is uncertain whether America will continue to live up to this ideal if the ‘free and fair’ element of its elections becomes questionable, and if elections repeatedly become an occasion where both parties claim victory while accusing the other of unconstitutional deception. Renewed violence and mass protest across multiple states would not be surprising in such a chaotic situation.
With no true agreement within American society over who won the 2020 presidential election, and the conceivable prospect of more disputes over election results in future, is America’s democracy unravelling before our very eyes?
It seems that there exist two Americas with two very different outlooks- a reality which could be deemed inimical to democracy itself
Some suggest that only a reboot of America’s current constitutional operating system can rescue American democracy from calamity. Of course, it was the mechanism of the Electoral College which enabled Trump to win the presidency in 2016 despite a three million deficit in the popular vote. The dysfunction on Capitol Hill which boosted his candidacy in so many ways, meanwhile, is partly the fault of a system that established the Senate as a bulwark against change with its minoritarian rule. Some would argue that, if these deficiencies in the system are fixed, American democracy can be revived.
Such a solution may be appropriate if we were talking merely of America’s arguable democratic decline. But the true issue at hand seems to extend deeper: a problem of disintegration and the breakdown of national cohesion. A recent poll conducted by the Centre for Politics at the University of Virginia showed support rising for the secession of Republican “red” states or Democratic “blue” states. More than half of Trump voters and one in four Biden voters agreed at least “somewhat” that it was time to split the country. A quarter of Trump voters “strongly” agreed. It seems that there exist two Americas with two very different outlooks- a reality which could be deemed inimical to democracy itself.
Image: Michael Stokes via Wikimedia Commons

