Claypath GP performance figures revealed

By Anna Calzada and Waseem Mohamed

New data released by NHS Digital has revealed how well GPs across England and Wales are performing in delivering in-person and same-day appointments. 

The data shows that between August and October this year, Claypath & University Medical Group, (Durham’s local GP) 66.6% of appointments were held face-to-face, 11.8% were held on the same day they were requested and 0.8% were held over 28 days after being requested. The GP handled 33,407 appointments in the past three months.

In comparison to the national average, Claypath & University Medical Group holds a slightly lower percentage of appointments face-to-face, but holds a higher number of appointments requested on the same day as the booking, and a much lower percentage of appointments being held over 28 days after the booking.

The figures show that there has been a significant national decrease in the proportion of consultations happening on the day they were requested, with one in five appointments being delayed by more than two weeks. Of the 6,357 GPs in England that provided data, 821 held less than 50% of their appointments in-person. A further 2,982 GPs held between 50-75% in-person, and 2,509 GPs achieved between 75-100% on in-person appointments.

NHS Digital says the aim of the data release is “to inform users about activity and usage of GP appointments historically and how primary care is impacted by seasonal pressures, such as winter”. It is hoped the data will allow patients to make a more informed choice about the GP they choose to register with. 

“It is really no more than a way to name and shame practices when the morale of dedicated staff is at rock bottom”

dr kieran sharrock

However, some GPs say the data publication is an example of “naming and shaming” practices. Dr Kieran Sharrock, chairman of the BMA GP committee, said the data does not factor in the size and age of the populations served by a surgery: “None of these nuances are taken into account in [the] data.” 

Sharrock says that “rather than this being a useful tool to aid patient choice, it is really no more than a way to name and shame practices when the morale of dedicated staff is at rock bottom”. The Government’s Health Secretary, Steve Barclay, insisted that the publication of the data aims to assist patients when deciding who to choose as their GP. 

The data release comes as GPs face increasing demands on their services. Last month at a BMA conference, health bosses proposed a new motion to cut core GP working hours, which are currently set from 8am to 6.30pm. 

Demands were also made for the withdrawal of the extended hours contracts which came into force in October. The contract requires that GPs see patients between 9am and 5pm on Saturdays and weekday evenings from 6.30pm and 8pm.

Many GP’s claim that these working hours disproportionately affect and discriminate against female GPs with young families, as the longer hours result in increased stress and workloads without considering the pressures of raising young children. 

Dr Paul Evans of the Gateshead and Tyneside committee, who was the first to suggest the motion calling for reduced hours, admitted he knew “too many GPs” who turned down permanent roles “because of the hours and because they cannot see a way to make it work with childcare opening hours and with family life”.

Palatinate contacted Claypath and University Medical Group for comment about the data release but did not receive a response. 

Image Credit: Roger Smith via Creative Commons