China’s inherent contradiction
By Lara Santos Ayllón
China has peaked on the scale of international influence, settling in the epicentre of the most prominent matters concerning the international community. The empire’s economic revival and return to the Big League towards the end of the 20th century happened suddenly, and it is clear that China’s intention is to stay, demonstrated by Mr Xi’s presence and strategic stance at the World Economic Forum that took place this January, in Davos. Contrary to Deng Xiaoping’s focus on internal affairs, Xi Jinping is aiming for increased external influence, establishing the roots for a different world order, one not designed only from Western values, methods and ideologies.
All of this may generate a positive balance in the international hegemonic order, for China’s prominence can act as America´s leash. However, China’s case compromises the international community’s integrity, for the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) continues to jeopardise human rights in China, (freedom of speech, individual liberties, obliteration of Tibetan communities, amongst other examples) whilst other major countries condone this due to the extent of China’s regional and global influence. This subordination of human rights values is visible when analysing the extent (or lack of) reactions from some influential players in the international community to China’s actions in Tibet, for example. Although the nation’s behaviour regarding human rights and international guidelines has been avidly verbally criticised, the overall reaction and calibre of measures taken are rarely on par. It appears that China is having her cake and eating it too, and that nothing can be done to stop her.
Recent domestic policy in China is a vast contributor to the individualist attitude that the nation maintains and bolsters within, in stark contrast to its efforts to expand both its political and economic influence internationally. Whereas Jian Zemin and Hu Jintao’s mandates were drizzled with leniency and decentralisation, Mr Xi swiftly began re-rooting power in the elite from 2012, when he came into office. The 19th National Congress re-established Mr Xi as General Secretary for a second term, and his rhetoric was uncompromising, taking a hard line on Hong Kong and reiterating the Chinese model as the best model. He further enshrined ‘Xi Jinping Thought’ establishing his pervasiveness within Chinese ideology and personalising CCP leadership, a major pillar of legitimacy during the Mao era. Even the minimal levels of accountability pertaining to the Chinese government are at risk in the near future – already there is speculation that Xi Jinping will prevail as president for a third consecutive turn, thus overturning the established two-term maximum.
A recent article published by The Economist expands on Mr Xi’s aim for China to become a ‘socialist cultural superpower’ through the revival of traditional Chinese culture. The use of demagogic Communist rhetoric and bolstering of some, carefully selected norms and values developed by Confucius, have long been used to trigger and accentuate national conscience and sentiment. The efforts to establish and build upon ‘cultural confidence’ by Mr Xi are both reinstating the CCP’s grip on power and building towards isolationist attitudes within Chinese society. ‘Xi Jinping’s Thought’ has now been dedicated departments within universities, and ‘study groups’ are being promoted across the country’. Paradoxically, Mr Xi is simultaneously 1 Lee, S., (2017) An Institutional Analysis of Xi Jinping’s Centralization of Power. China into the most influential international circles and organisations, defiantly branding the nation as a ‘Chinese democracy’.
China’s role as one of the key actors involved in global affairs is evident regarding the current North Korean nuclear crisis. Pragmatic, China has taken a cautious step away from her ally to support the non-proliferation demands of the rest of the international community, although rejecting further sanctions proposed by the United States. In this scenario, Uncle Sam’s threats of proceeding without China’s consent are unlikely to materialise due to the strong economic dependence between the two nations. Currently, the United States and North Korea find themselves in a deadlock of threats with little progress. Furthermore, the United States’ recent reluctance to cooperate with the existing global order, such as during the Paris climate negotiations, has been critical for China to wedge itself in further as a key actor, in spite of its lack of compliance with international norms and expectations.
So China is making history, managing its allies and rivals whilst purporting its status quo. The CCP’s strategic use of foreign policy enables it to foster its Machiavellian domestic policy whilst maintaining Western compliance. How long can this last? Observing current developments in Chinese and global politics, there are various threats that can jeopardise the PRC’s current form of government. To remain a global power the CCP must implement further changes to their economic policy and increasingly embrace market initiatives, through which foreign influence will inevitably affect the Chinese population’s perception of government and lifestyle. Furthermore, the Renminbi internationalization is already on the CCP’s radar, and if China becomes an integral player in global financial markets it will have to accommodate the effects of this policy on the population and their access to global information and initiatives.
Nonetheless, Mr Xi has clamped down on corruption and is creating an aura of increasing welfare which, coupled with the reinforcement of Confucian, traditional values and the existing ‘petitioning’ system through which Chinese citizens can voice their views on government could potentially counteract any possible waves of democratization. The recent rise of populism in the West, which imperil the stability of democracy, is also a potential weapon for the CCP to portray the authoritarian state as the ‘appropriate’ system for China.
Regardless, ideological populisms are not linked to institutional layout, which in the West remains democratic, and this has not been questioned or overturned. The PRC may have escaped the democratic wave that washed over the world in the 20th century, but authoritarian rule is set to be continuously challenged. With China, however, the process of change is likely to take a little more time.
Photograph: Osrin via Flickr
