Chengdu earthquake reveals flaws in China’s zero-Covid policy

By Hannah Langlois

Whilst Coronavirus may feel like last year’s news for the UK, other countries have opted for a very different approach when managing outbreaks, with no policy appearing more stringent than that enforced in China. Tackling the virus remains top priority to the Chinese government even when faced by calamitous events such as the 6.8 magnitude earthquake in Chengdu earlier this month. This brings into question whether priorities really lie in public health, or alternatively in saving face. 

The earthquake that struck Chengdu last week claimed the lives of at least 70 and left many more injured and displaced. The capital of Sichuan province is an earthquake prone area due to its location along the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau, however Covid measures trumped earthquake safety procedures as residents were forbidden from leaving their homes. Whilst videos on social media show people attempting to break out from behind iron gates, security remained tight, and people were ordered to remain inside their homes despite the after-effects that coincide with earthquakes. 

This response from the authorities adds further fuel to the population’s frustration as these harsh lockdown measures have been in place almost three years since the first coronavirus cases were reported in China in 2019. Ultimately, China’s zero-Covid policy aims to maximise suppression of the virus through mass testing and strict lockdowns. Despite Thursday’s report of 116 new cases in a city of 21 million, any relaxation of restrictions is wishful thinking.

This paints a very different picture to the living with Covid approach adopted in the UK – but then admittedly, China is in a very different situation to us regarding vaccinations. The government is refusing to buy foreign produced vaccines and ultimately doesn’t want to admit its failure to its citizens and economic friends and foes on the global stage.

Chengdu’s earthquake is very much a physical representation of the growing cracks in China’s economy, as unemployment soars and exports fall due to harsh lockdowns that prevent people from attending work. Lockdowns are crushing for productivity, especially in a city like Chengdu which is considered a crucial economic and commercial hub in China. It is vital not to forget the human impact, especially the harmful effects enforced quarantines have on mental health. Countless studies have shown how extended periods of lockdown lead to increased loneliness and depression due to a dramatic decrease in social interaction. In a city where much of the population reside in apartments in six-storey buildings, and you’re only allowed to leave the house once a day to go food-shopping, it could really feel like the walls are closing in.

Chengdu’s earthquake is very much a physical representation of the growing cracks in China’s economy

The collateral damage seems hardly worth it; it appears that zero-Covid policy is doing far more harm than good. If the government’s priority is truly to protect its citizens from Covid-19, surely there are other policies they could put in place that would aid the public health crisis without damaging the economy and the sanity of its people in the process? There are plenty of examples to follow and lessons to be learnt from other countries around the globe that could inform how China implements solutions such as vaccination rollout. 

However, for those in the policy-making position, pride on the international stage remains the highest priority. Chinese vaccines are simply not yet as effective as those produced by the likes of Pfizer and AstraZeneca, but the country refuses to administer a vaccine that hasn’t been produced within its borders. Despite the drastic blows to China’s economy caused by zero-Covid policy, there remains a stubbornness in China’s pandemic tactics that is threatening more than just the population’s health. 

Events such as this earthquake bring the world’s attention back to the long days in lockdown that we’re all keen to leave in the past. The sad reality is that this is still a source of everyday anxiety for some. Authorities plough forwards in the name of national pride – an abstract concept that many countries have abandoned in favour of a return to normality. It is only a matter of time before China will have to give in to Western-produced vaccinations and give up its potentially detrimental policy.

Image credit: Xiangkun ZHU via Unsplash