Labour’s Energy Plan: An Alluring Alternative?

By Ellen Fasham

The recent unveiling of both the Conservative and Labour Party’s plans to tackle the imminent energy crisis are a response to the impending winter which, without intervention, will leave many households across the UK with a choice between buying groceries or paying energy bills. In August, Keir Starmer presented the party’s plan to tackle this crisis. Last week, Liz Truss did the same. Labour’s plan, whilst hypothetical, is firmly positioned as the alternative to the Government’s proposal. It is an alternative which to many voters may seem more appealing.

Like the Tories’ proposal, the Labour plan is brazenly simple. The energy price cap would be frozen at the existing rate of £1971 per annum, lower than the Conservative’s proposed cap of £2,500. The government would then pay the difference, essentially subsidising the cost of energy. Under both proposals, every household in the UK would receive the same means of support, despite differences in income. This is poorly targeted: while the highest earners might find a £4000 manageable (if aggravating), the lowest earners would find it financially devastating. However, the enormous scale of the crisis means that its impacts would not be limited to the lowest income households, and indeed the majority of households would significantly struggle to foot a £4000 energy bill. Furthermore, the Conservative’s proposed cut to National Insurance Tax would even further exacerbate the differences of real support provided to the highest and lowest earners, with estimates suggesting the highest 1/10th of earners would receive almost double the take-home benefits than the lowest 1/10th. When considered alongside tax cuts, Labour’s plan addresses situational needs in a way the Conservatives’ does not.

The short-termism of both policies is arguably a necessary ill. Structural changes would be imprudent in such a precarious economic environment.

The Labour plan has been criticised for its short-termism. While the Conservatives will cap energy prices for the next two years, Labour’s proposal would only be ensured for the next 6 months. However, both plans warrant calls to seek a more sustainable energy policy, rather than urgent state intervention at the eleventh hour. These calls are legitimate, but both plans fail to suggest long-term, structural changes to the energy industry. In particular, there also need to be substantial measures to address the inevitable long-term economic effects of significant borrowing, as suggested in Liz Truss’ plan. However, the short-termism of both policies is arguably a necessary ill. Structural changes would be imprudent in such a precarious economic environment. Both plans satisfy the immediate need for urgent relief.

The most significant difference between the two plans is the method of funding. The Labour plan would cost £29bn and would be paid for mostly by a backdated Windfall Tax on oil and gas companies. The plan would also halt Boris Johnson’s proposed £400 handout, with the rest, Labour argues, financed by a reduction in annual debt interest payments. Liz Truss will not stop the proposed handouts and has made clear that a Windfall Tax will not be instated – rather, the plan will be funded by borrowing. With the plan costing between £100bn-£250 bn, this is a colossal price tag. It is also a gamble and could mean that the burden of borrowing might eventually fall onto the taxpayer. Granted, a Windfall Tax does carry the danger of deterring investment into energy companies, a particular concern considering the current vulnerability of the market. Regardless, many agree with Ursula von der Leyen’s argument that “it is wrong [for energy companies] to receive extraordinary record profits benefiting from war and on the back of consumers”. Labour’s plan, therefore, may hold a greater allure for voters who are all too sharply feeling the burden of an acute global crisis.

The boldness of Labour’s energy plan indicates a new direction for Starmer, who has often been accused of not providing any concrete alternative to the Tory leadership he criticises. In proposing such action, Labour has presented themselves as a viable alternative to the existing government. It may well be that the Conservative’s seemingly incautious approach to borrowing may alter their perception as the party of economic prudence. Only time will tell whether the Truss’s proposal will garner enough popularity until the next general election – or whether the Labour party will stand as a more attractive alternative.

Image: Mark Morgan via Flickr