Castle MCR pledges £25k to acquire use of Palace Green almshouses

By Luke Payne

Castle MCR is planning an ambitious expansion of their existing common room facilities into the 17th Century Palace Green Bishop Cosin’s Almshouses, also known as Café on the Green. The common room has committed £25,000 to the total cost of the acquisition of the central Bailey site and all necessary refurbishments required. Despite the significant cost the proposal, the common room’s ordinary members have yet to be consulted.

According to the MCR Treasurer’s most recent report, the common room plans to use the building for exclusive additional space for its members and sees the acquisition as a long-term investment. The plans have been in the works for some time, as the previous President and Treasurer commenced work on the project.  The executive hopes the acquisition will be finalised early next year.

Castle MCR is one of the wealthiest common rooms but the sum pledged to the building will represent a substantial portion of its finances. Its acquired wealth has recently been the subject of controversy as, last year, Palatinate revealed it had historically profited thousands of pounds from its annual charity balls.

“They are not very transparent with budgets”

Member of Castle MCR

When told about the plans by Palatinate, an ordinary member described them as “unfair”, believing they had no say on where their money goes and went on to reveal; “They are not very transparent with budgets. We have been asked to pay membership fees this year and received little in return. It feels like our money is being used to refurbish something for future students.”

The refurbishments of the building will likely be extensive and costly, as the building’s roof requires replacement. Reports acquired by Palatinate show the building’s loft space is filled with asbestos, which will require removal by professionals. The Almshouses’ listed status and location on a world heritage site will likely exacerbate these costs greatly. The common room may also face stiff competition from other departments of the University, as Palatinate understands there are multiple parties interested in acquiring the building.

The building dates from 1668 and was designed by John Longstaffe for then Bishop of Durham, John Cosin. Almshouses were buildings that provided accommodation for poor people who could not afford to pay rent such as retired or elderly members of the community. The Palace Green Almshouses has, until recently, been the home of Café on the Green, a Durham University business.

When approached for comment with respect to the acquisition the Castle MCR President provided the following statement: “The MCR has grown significantly over the last three years, averaging ~270 members. The Maurice Tucker room is currently insufficient to meet the needs of the MCR and so the previous exec (2019/20) decided to investigate options to expand our physical space.

“After the lease of the Cafe-on-the-Green ended, the University decided to start exploring other uses for this building and the previous Castle exec and Principal investigated this as a possibility for the new location of the MCR.

“Before taking this proposal to the MCR, we first needed to establish that the space was in fact available which, as of today, is still not confirmed. No decisions have been made regarding use of this space since nothing has been confirmed. However, the exec will engage in a broad consultative process should it be decided to proceed with this acquisition.”

Image: Peter Bonnett via Flickr