Casting Hamlet
By Laura Sadler
Reading a review of the Theatre Royal Windsor’s current production of Hamlet, the images jar slightly as my mind tries to register a man upwards of 80, garbed in ‘youthful’ clothes (hoodies, skinny jeans). Usually, when I think of the Dane, a young Laurence Olivier, a mad Mad-Max era Mel Gibson or even the dashing David Oakes who I saw at the Rose Theatre York one summer, come to mind. The Guardian notes director Sean Mathias’ decision to perform this production age-blind as an ‘inspired… innovation’, but beyond the stage itself, what this may say about the exclusivity of the world of theatre is troublesome.
I watched Ian McKellen play King Lear a few years ago, and he was spectacular. McKellen was moving, gripping, and pathetic in a part which, demanding a great deal of skill and maturity, seemed almost perfectly designed as his swan song, and would have been a triumphant end to a long career on the Shakespearean stage.
Talking with my partner, he argued that McKellen now claims a prerogative to play the most sought-after and prestigious roles in all British, perhaps even global, theatre, whatever they may be. His extensive contribution to drama and his talent justify the privilege to finish his career in whichever role he wishes. Just like the 36-year-old Ronaldo playing upfront at Man United, he maintained, those who have proved their worth have a right to their place.
The production is likely to benefit from the gravitas and maturity of a more experience actor to spotlight the metaphysical and psychological potential which other productions sometime bypass
So, McKellen has come back singing and has been given the opportunity to revise an iconic role, he once played in his salad days (aged 31, 1971). One would expect, given the complex nuances of Hamlet, that 50 years on, he will bring out a very different side to the tragic protagonist. I expect that some of the cruder humour is unlikely to wash; this is perhaps why Hamlet’s romantic entanglement with Ophelia is removed from this production. Concurrently, the production is likely to benefit from the gravitas and maturity of a more experienced actor to spotlight the metaphysical and psychological potential which other productions sometimes bypass.
It’s hard to counter a pervading suspicion that this could be case of ‘bums on seats’, a decision made on post-lockdown commercial prospects, rather than an ‘inspired innovation’ to revolutionise theatre
However, I can’t help feeling that his recent casting is a kick in the teeth for our young upcoming generation of performers. Theatre has suffered under government arts cuts, and the pandemic dealt another significant blow that will be felt for many years. In this gloomy world in which we look to theatre as escapism, it must feel disquieting as a young actor, seeing a part which the original text places around 30, being given to an actor in his retiring years. One expects McKellen to be slowing down on stage and perhaps transitioning to a life behind it, while many young actors are desperate for the exposure and prestige this role would bring. It’s hard to counter a pervading suspicion that this could be a case of ‘bums on seats’, a decision made on post-lockdown commercial prospects, rather than an ‘inspired innovation’ to revolutionise theatre. After all, seeing a famous white man on stage is hardly radical.
At the same time, Cush Jumbo (who recently starred in Britbox original The Beast Must Die) is coming right into the peak of her career and has been cast simultaneously as Hamlet in The Young Vic’s production. This is good casting, and despite the poor production overall, Jumbo has excellent reviews. There are few great Shakespearean parts written directly for women, and none for BAME women. It’s fantastic to have more inclusive and more accessible theatre which can give a young female star a role like this, so coveted and which in its difficulty and depth, clearly allows her talent to shine. Gender-swapping is now typical in modern productions, but has often been fluid in the theatre, from 17th-century boy actors playing the Renaissance Ophelia to the Christmas pantomime scene.
As we continue to revive classic drama, blind casting is a great alternative for a director who prefers retaining the text or characters of the origianl play, as opposed to rewriting in a gender, age or colour concious way
Overall, I think blind casting is a good thing; it allows anyone to perform in an arena historically fairly exclusive to those from certain walks of life. Of course, it would be great if new, leading parts were written and designed for POCs, women, disabilities. Yet, as we continue to revive classic drama, blind casting is a great alternative for a director who prefers retaining the text or characters of the original play, as opposed to rewriting in a gender, age or colour conscious way.
However, this type of casting must be done to create opportunities, not to cut them out. If the Theatre Royal Windsor’s next production casts an age-blind King Lear of just 25, then equilibrium will be found. Otherwise, let’s give our new stars, like Jumbo, a chance to play theatre’s most distinguished role. After all, as Uncle Monty tells us: “It is the most shattering experience of a young man’s life when one morning he awakes and quite reasonably says to himself ‘I will never play the Dane.’” Perhaps, I conjecture, that’s exactly how our new generation is feeling.
Image credit: Matty Hibel via Flickr
Facebook Indigo Stage Contributors: (join to write for us!): https://www.facebook.com/groups/1105139026203785

