Calls for universities to lower entry requirements for poor students
A recent government report has emphasised the need to widen access to university education.
The report, headed by former Labour minister Alan Milburn, proposes measures to increase the number of students from poor backgrounds at university.
His recommendations for universities include using “contextual data” when setting entry requirements for applicants.
Milburn states “Universities should offer guaranteed interviews and, where appropriate, lower offers to less-advantaged pupils in schools they support.”
By examining family income and social background, universities could take into account factors affecting a student’s grades, ensuring selection is based on potential and talent.
However critics have expressed concern that the move would risk discriminating against middle-class and privately educated students, who may consequently have to gain even higher grades to secure their place.
According to Milburn, universities should not just focus on widening access at the point of application.
Milburn highlights the success of the outreach programmes currently developed by many universities. Programmes such as summer camps and coaching are often fundamental in encouraging poor students to apply for further education.
Milburn believes outreach programmes and other forms of early intervention are just as crucial, and an alternative measure to lowering grade boundaries.
However, Dr Wendy Piatt, director general of the Russell Group, said: “Grades at GCSE, A-level or their equivalent are always hugely important, but they’re never the sole criterion.
“There are lots of other things we take into account, for example some universities interview candidates precisely because they want to make sure that any strengths that are not reflected in their A-level results are actually brought out”
Yet figures published in the report support Milburn’s claims that current measures by universities are not successfully widening access: the most privileged 20 per cent of teenagers are still seven times more likely to secure a place at a top university than the poorest 40 per cent.
Those closely involved with the inquiry seem to regard it as a significant turning point in efforts to increase numbers of poor students at university.
One source commented: “Universities now have a choice. They can either make more use of contextual data or they need to get out into the community to help children from disadvantaged backgrounds to achieve the necessary qualifications.”
Photograph: Flickr ID – comedy_nose

