Brazil’s deadliest police operation occurs in Rio de Janeiro
By Luisa Pittan Doring
“When they come in here, they kill even the rats.” With those words, Cláudia Silva described Rio’s police operations to The Guardian, as violence once again engulfed the Penha complex. Ms Silva is a local of Vila Cruzeiro, one of the favelas in Rio de Janeiro impacted by the “megaoperação”, a ‘police sting’ that took place on the 28th of October.
This operation was led by Batalhão de Operações Policiais Especiais (BOPE), Rio de Janeiro’s elite special operations police unit, and was ordered by the state governor Claudio Castro, member of the right-wing Liberal Party – the party of former president, Jair Bolsonaro. According to officials, the operation was initiated to attack the power of the Red Command, a Brazilian crime organisation, and pervaded global news, with many media outlets reporting on it. This is not, however, the first time a BOPE sting has erupted in Rio – raising questions regarding the increase in media coverage. Around 132 deaths have been confirmed by officials, making it the most deadly sting since May 6th, 2019. This 2019 operation was labelled a massacre by many critics, resulting in 29 deaths; nearly five times less than this most recent operation. The high death toll has prompted various global news reporters to question the legitimacy of the operation, and its intention to ‘eradicate crime’ – particularly given that various victims have not been confirmed to be affiliated to the Red Command.
Around 132 deaths have been confirmed by officials, making it the most deadly sting since May 6th, 2019
Leading up to the 28th, WhatsApp messages discussing torture methods had been intercepted between Red Command members in the Penha and Alemão complexes, the two areas targeted in the sting, permitting BOPE to intervene. A police force of 2,500 entered the two complexes in the early morning, with 50 buses being used to block traffic in the area. This prevented both potential criminals and innocent citizens alike from leaving the area, and resulting in a surge of robberies in the area. One of the main areas of contention involves accusations of brutality during the operation, with locals calling the police “murderers”, and describing the situation as “surreal”. Given that the death penalty was abolished in Brazil in 1988, critics have argued that BOPE’s role was to enter the area and arrest the criminals, rather than engaging with gunfire. Many also criticise the governor for unleashing disproportionate violence on the area, particularly considering that those targeted are low-level criminals, often used as pawns by criminal leaders. These leaders of organised crime, who live in luxury condominiums, travel by private jet, and run businesses internationally remain untouched. Human Rights Watch stated that although roughly half of Rio de Janeiro’s population is black, black residents disproportionately accounted for more than three-quarters of those killed by police in 2015 – an observation which prompted accusations of racial bias from critics.
The operation has faced criticism from within Brazil, with the Commission of Human Rights, led by the Brazilian Chamber of Deputies, calling for the preventative imprisonment of Governor Castro. The shock has also echoed internationally, with the United Nations Human Rights office expressing their horror at the high death toll.
Governor Castro has been vocal in his defence of the operation, saying that “if [police power] needs to be excessive, it will be excessive”
Governor Castro has been vocal in his defence of the operation, saying that “if [police power] needs to be excessive, it will be excessive.” However, for critics his claim conflicts with Action for Breach of a Fundamental Precept (ADPF) 635, a Supreme Court decision restricting police operations in Rio’s communities, following years of excessive force. In 2018 alone, 1,520 people were killed by police. The ruling was designed to prevent unchecked violence that critics argue has now unfolded again, especially as militias have tried to seek control near hospitals and schools. The governor justified the operation by alleging insufficient federal support – a claim made whilst President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva was on a 20-hour flight from Malaysia, delaying his response. However, the Minister of Justice has clarified that no request, known as a GLO (Guarantee of Law and Order), which authorises the deployment of the armed forces for public security, had been made. Governor Castro has blamed ADPF 635 for a rise in violence in the state, however, statistical evidence contradicts his claim: between 2019 and 2023, violent deaths in Rio fell by 18.4%, deaths in police operations dropped by 52%, and on-duty police deaths decreased by 50%. The ADPF’s restrictions have arguably not fueled insecurity, but rather helped mitigate it, casting doubt on the governor’s narrative. For residents like Cláudia Silva, violence is an everyday reality rather than a political debate.
Image credit: Ministerio da Defesa via Wikimedia Commons

