A modern age showgirl?

By Lucie Daniel

With no other artist to rival her magnitude, Taylor Swift has enjoyed a long streak of great success in recent years: the Eras tour being the first tour to gross over $2 Billion, receiving her fourth grammy award for her 2024 album Midnights, and her latest album The Tortured Poets Society breaking several records, debuting at number one on the Billboard 200 chart in 2024. That was until The Life of a Showgirl dropped on 3rd October 2025. After a rapid succession of music, many fans anticipated the pop singer to take a break from releasing music. But many also anticipated the re-release of Reputation (Swift’s sixth studio album), however, with the announcement of her gaining the rights to her old music shocking the world, we were left puzzled as to what she could possibly be meaning to release after only 18 months had passed since The Tortured Poets Society.

It was safe to say that all the evidence pointed to a U-turn in Swift’s music: away from the ballads and the heartbroken tracks of her recent albums back towards the sparkly, clean, relatable pop image that Swift originally was renowned for in Fearless, Red, and 1989. The new album polarised fans from the beginning. Some Swifties yearned for the days of Evermore and Folklore, with their beautiful lyricism and storytelling. Others welcomed the change, seeing this as a return to the ‘lover-girl’ era of Swift’s music brought about by Swift’s new relationship with Travis Kelce.

The showgirl as Swift’s new persona for this era was an interesting turn for this album to take, and one that wasn’t all that surprising to fans

The Showgirl as Swift’s new persona for this era was an interesting turn for this album to take, and one that wasn’t all that surprising to fans. The Eras tour lasted for 21 months, each show being three and a half hours long, and being shown in 51 different cities. It’s clear that Swift has earned her title as the ‘showgirl’. The image of the showgirl evokes a certain level of vapidness, being dedicated to performance and nothing else – a mere façade. This is similar to earlier imagery in Swift’s discography, like ‘Mirrorball’ and ‘Bejeweled’, which both centre on the performer’s ability to remain outwardly poised whilst battling internal conflicts and anxieties. The album entangles the nostalgic with the voyeuristic, a complexity reminiscent of Old Hollywood. This is most clear in the album cover featuring a half-submerged image of Taylor Swift, dressed in her showgirl garb. This engages with the polarising demands of a public persona where you are constantly drowning but also putting on a show in your most vulnerable moments.

The promotional roll-out for this album could be described as nothing less than extortionate. With 27 different versions of the album for pre-order, this repulsed a large section of the fanbase, inciting claims that Swift was taking a calculated move in monopolising on collector-culture. Fans felt not only disrespected, but disappointed. Especially with the quality of the images they were given, bearing in mind the album itself was yet to be released. So, issues with the album were already brewing before the momentous day of its release, which is why, when it finally did come out, fans poured out on social media how much the album was a let-down, with various comments like “We are living in an era where Benson Boone is a better lyricist than Taylor Swift” on the TikTok account @coolgirl3331, gaining 133K likes.

To have such a monumental and colossal figure in the music industry have to come to her own defence and say “if it’s the first week of my album release and you’re saying either my name or my album title then you’re helping” in an interview for Apple Music with Zane Lowe, then something has gone significantly wrong. For me, I think there is a major disconnect between what fans envisioned from the past works of Swift and what we were delivered. This gap reads like inauthenticity, especially in our current political climate where billionaires are coming under more and more scrutiny as to how their wealth and power contributes to global issues like the climate crisis and the poverty gap.

It feels like she’s still putting on a performance. When we expected a confession, we saw her double-down

We envisioned a peek behind the curtain at how demanding and taxing the showgirl life really is, perhaps some scrap of relatability left behind from previous albums; we were instead left with what felt like a boasting, performative album which was rather mean in some parts (particularly ‘actually romantic’ and ‘Cancelled!’). Therefore, we stay on the surface, at arm’s length, rather than receiving the psychologically profound picture we once had of Swift’s mind. Detaching herself from her own art and fading into the persona of the showgirl, we are left with the words “I’m immortal now, baby dolls” instead of anything constructive or revelatory about how her reality really is. It feels like she’s still putting on a performance. When we expected a confession, we saw her double-down.

Image: Wikimedia Commons