Booker Prize Rule Change: A Blow for British Novelists

man booker photo online 300x200

By Louisa Cursons

Last month it was announced that the Man Booker Prize, formerly open only to the Commonwealth, Zimbabwe and the Republic of Ireland, will extend its reach to include any novel published in English in this country. Consequently, the 2014 Prize will be available to thousands of esteemed American writers whose novels have successfully reached the UK.

Unsurprisingly, this announcement has sparked fierce concerns among British novelists that their work won’t even get a look-in when competing with such a vast range of different authors and styles. The rule change appears to give a clear advantage to major publishers, whose novels are more likely to be singled out, while less renowned companies will be drowned in the sea of books up for consideration. The discovery of fresh literary talent therefore becomes unlikely, as the underdogs are utterly eclipsed by the thousands of revered international novelists now included.

This decision also highlights a growing national concern: that British culture is slowly but surely becoming infiltrated by its overseas companions. The Man Booker Prize was a symbol of British individuality, providing the country with something of its own; a platform for national literary achievement. The Americans have their own equivalents, in the form of the American Book Awards and the National Book Awards. Both of these accolades are only open to American writers, excluding Britain and the rest of the world. Why, then, has Britain chosen to renounce one of the few establishments that was unique to itself, in order to allow the Americans a look-in?

the underdogs are utterly eclipsed by the thousands of revered international novelists now included

One argument might be that British writers will benefit from this fresh competition, pushing them to surpass American literature. Of course, it also encourages integration and equality between the different cultures, providing writers from any background with a fantastic opportunity. However, these opportunities were already being provided through the Man Booker International Prize, an award available to authors of any nationality for a body of work published in English. In fact, the previous two winners were American: Philip Roth in 2011 and Lydia Davis in 2013. Is it really necessary, therefore, to extend the reach of the Man Booker Prize?

What’s more, it was decided earlier this year to create a new international award for literature entitled the Folio Prize, which is open to all works of fiction written in English and published in the UK. This award will be given for the first time in 2014; the same year that the Booker Prize is set to change its admission rules. It seems that next year, Britain will be offering awards to a multitude of international authors, at the expense of its British novelists. Jim Crace, an author shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize this year, told the London Evening Standard that the changes to the Prize will devalue it, making it seem “less essential” to writers in the UK.

It appears that the UK is fated to have to share its creations with America, from The X Factor to the Booker Prize. Unfortunately, this fact may impair the chances of British authors of gaining the praise and renown that they deserve.

Photograph: Nicolas Heath